Table 2. Case-control studies of soft tissue sarcoma and non-Hodgkin lymphoma.
Reference | Country | Cases | Controls | Method of exposure assessment | Comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hardell et al 1979 [5] | Sweden | 21 living and 31 deceased men aged 26-80 who had been admitted to a hospital with STS during 1970-77 | 206 men (up to 4 per case) matched for sex, age (±5 years), vital status and place of residence or death | Self-administered questionnaire completed by subject or next of kin, supplemented by blinded telephone interview | |
Eriksson et al 1981 [6] | Sweden | 110 patients with STS diagnosed during 1974-78 in 5 counties | 219 controls (up to 2 per case) matched by age, municipality, vital status and year of death, and employment within 5 years of case’s retirement or death | Self-administered questionnaire completed by subject or next of kin, supplemented by blinded telephone interview | |
Greenwald et al 1984 [43] | USA | 281 men with STS diagnosed during 1962-80 and registered in New York State, who were aged 18-29 during 1962-71 | 281 living men from driver’s license files, individually matched for 5-year period of birth and area of residence, plus 130 deceased controls for deceased cases | Telephone interview of subject or next of kin, or in-person interview if requested | |
Hoar et al 1986 [44] | USA | Men with new STS (133), NHL (170) and Hodgkin’s disease (121) during 1976-82 identified from cancer registry for Kansas State | 948 men from general population individually matched on age vital status and year of death | Telephone interview of subject or next of kin | Data on NHL later included in pooled analysis by De Roos et al 2003 [45]. |
Vineis et al 1986 [46] | Italy | 68 men and women aged ≥20 from three provinces with proved or suspected histological diagnosis of STS during 1981-83 | 122 men and women selected from electoral registers and 36 selected from death records | Inference by blinded experts from job descriptions elicited from subject or next of kin at interview or (for 16 cases and 37 referents) by postal questionnaire | |
Smith and Pearce 1986 [47] | New Zealand | 133 men with histologically confirmed STS registered during 1976-82 | 407 men with other registered cancers | Telephone interview of subject or next of kin | Extends Smith et 1984 [48], and subsumes Smith et al 1983 [49]. |
Woods et al 1987 [50] | USA | Men aged 20-79 in 13 counties of Washington State with STS (128) and NHL (576) diagnosed during 1981-84 | 694 men from general population, individually matched for vital status and age, identified through random digit dialling, social security records and death records | In-person interview | Subsumes Woods and Polissar 1989 [51]. |
Pearce et al 1987 [52] | New Zealand | 183 men aged >70 with histologically confirmed NHL registered during 1977-81 | 338 men with other registered cancers | Telephone interview of subject or next of kin | Subsumes Pearce et al 1986 [53]. |
Olsson and Brandt 1988 [54] | Sweden | 167 men aged 20-81 admitted to oncology department in Lund during 1978-81 with NHL | 50 men from population register for same geographical area as cases plus 80 men from different parts of Sweden (originally controls for other studies) | Interview | Second control group inappropriate because from different geographical areas. Interviews not blinded. |
Zahm et al 1990 [55] | USA | White men aged ≥21 from 66 counties of Nebraska with NHL (201), Hodgkin’s disease, multiple myeloma or CLL diagnosed during 1983-86 | 725 white men from general population frequency matched for race, vital status and age, identified through random digit dialling, social security records and death records | Telephone interview of subject or next of kin | Subsumes Weisenberger 1990 [56]. Later included in pooled analysis by De Roos et al 2003 [45]. |
Dalager et al 1991 [57] | USA | 201 male Vietnam-era veterans born during 1937-54 with NHL diagnosed and treated in Veterans Affairs hospitals during 1969-85 | 358 male Vietnam-era veterans who were in-patients at Veterans Affairs hospitals and individually matched for birth date, hospital and year of discharge from hospital | Self-administered questionnaire completed by subject or next of kin, supplemented by telephone interview | |
Cantor et al 1992 [58] | USA | 622 men aged ≥30 from Iowa and parts of Minnesota with histologically confirmed NHL diagnosed during 1981-83 (Iowa) and 1980-82 (Minnesota) | 1,245 white men frequency matched by 5-year age group, vital status and state of residence, selected from random digit dialling, Medicare records and death certificate files | In-person interview with subject or proxy. | Later included in pooled analysis by De Roos et al 2003 [45]. |
Smith and Christophers 1992 [59] | Australia | 30 men aged ≥30 with STS registered at six Melbourne hospitals during 1982-88 and still alive at time of study | Patients registered with other cancers and people selected from electoral register, individually matched for sex, age and current area of residence | Interview | |
Hardell et al 1994 [60] | Sweden | 105 men aged 25-85 admitted to an oncology department with NHL during 1974-78 | 335 men from general population, individually matched for age, place of residence, vital status and year of death | Self-administered questionnaire completed by patient or next of kin and supplemented by telephone interview where necessary. | Subsumes Hardell et al 1981 [7]. |
Kogevinas et al 1995 [61] | 11 countriesa | 11 cases of STS and 32 of NHL identified from death certificates and cancer registrations in an international cohort study | Five controls per case, individually matched for sex, age and country, selected by incidence density sampling (information on exposure missing for 2 controls) | Inferred from employment records by a panel of hygienists blinded to case/control status | Overlaps Kogevinas et al 1997 [22] and Lynge 1998 [31]. |
Tatham et al 1997 [62] | USA | 1,048 living men born 1929-53 with NHL diagnosed during 1984-88 and registered at one of 8 cancer registries | 1,659 men from general population, frequency matched for registry and date of birth (in 5-year bands), identified through random digit dialling | Telephone interview | |
Fontana et al 1998 [63] | Italy | 180 patients aged 20-74 with NHL, Hodgkin’s disease or CLL during 1991-93 at four hospitals | Random sample from general population, frequency matched for sex and age | In-person interview | Methods poorly described. |
Hardell and Eriksson 1999 [64] | Sweden | 404 men aged ≥25 years from 7 Swedish counties with NHL diagnosed during 1987-90 | 741 men from general population, individually matched for age, county, vital status and year of death | Self-administered questionnaire completed by subject or next of kin, supplemented by telephone interview if necessary | |
Persson and Fredrikson 1999 [65] | Sweden | 199 surviving patients aged 20-79 from 2 regions with NHL registered during 1964-86 | 479 adults form the same populations, randomly selected from population registers | Postal questionnaire | Subsumes Persson et al 1989 [66] and Persson et al1993 [67]. |
Miligi et al 2003 [68] | Italy | 1,145 adults aged 20-74 from 11 areas of Italy with newly diagnosed NHL or CLL during 1990-93 | 1,232 people randomly selected from general population with frequency matching for sex and age | In-person interview of subject or proxy with expert inference of exposure to specific pesticides based on questionnaire data | Miligi et al 2006 [69] is based on same study. |
Fritschi et al 2005 [70] | Australia | 694 adults aged 20-74 from 2 Australian states with NHL first diagnosed 2000-01 | 694 adults randomly selected from electoral roll and frequency matched for sex, age and region of residence | Postal questionnaire supplemented by interview in those with relevant jobs | |
Hartge et al 2005 [71] | USA | 1,321 adults aged 20-74 from 3 geographical areas with NHL diagnosed 1998-2000 (excluded a random subset of whites in two areas) | 1,057 adults from general population, frequency matched for sex, age, race and area, identified through random digit dialling or Medicare records | In-person interview and measurement of dust samples in home | |
Mills et al 2005 [72] | USA | 60 cases of NHL incident during 1987-2001 among 139,000 members of a farm workers’ union in California | 300 controls from same cohort with no history of cancer, matched for sex, age and Hispanic ethnicity | Linkage of job histories to records of pesticide applications by month, county and crop | |
Orsi et al 2008 [73] | France | Men aged 20-75 from 6 French centres with recently diagnosed NHL (244) and CLL (77) during 2000-04 | 456 hospital patients mainly from orthopaedic and rheumatological departments | In-person interview with supplementary telephone interview if needed. | |
Eriksson et al 2008 [74] | Sweden | 910 patients aged 18-74 from 4 regions with histologically confirmed NHL newly diagnosed during 1999-2002 | 1,016 adults randomly selected from population registers and frequency matched for sex and age | Postal questionnaire | |
Pahwa et al 2011 [75] | Canada | 357 men aged ≥19 years from 6 provinces with STS diagnosed during 1991-94 | 1,506 men from general population, identified from health insurance records, telephone listings and voters’ lists | Postal questionnaire (subject or proxy) supplemented by interview | Subsumes Pahwa et al 2006 [76]. |
Pahwa et al 2012 [77] | Canada | 513 men aged ≥19 years from 6 provinces with NHL diagnosed during 1991-94 | 1,506 men from general population, frequency matched for age, identified from health insurance records, telephone listings and voters’ lists | Postal questionnaire (subject or proxy) supplemented by interview in subjects with more intensive exposure to pesticides | Subsumes McDuffie et al 2001 [78] and Hohenadel et al 2011 [79]. |
Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Sweden, UK