Table 2.
Renal mass biopsy series and nondiagnostic rate.
Study | Biopsies | Nondiagnostic biopsy rate | Nondiagnostic definition |
---|---|---|---|
Maturen et al.[2007] | 152 | 6 (3.9%) | Insufficient tissue |
Volpe et al.[2008] | 100 | 16 (16%) | Insufficient tissue |
1 RCC of 2 repeat biopsies | |||
Prince et al.[2014] | 565 | 83 (14.7%) | Necrosis/fibrosis |
Insufficient tissue | |||
Leveridge et al.[2011] | 345 | 67 (19.4%) | Nonrenal tissue |
Insufficient tissue | |||
12 repeat biopsies revealed 8 RCCs | |||
Lebret et al.[2007] | 119 | 25 (21%) | Necrosis |
Inflammation | |||
13 repeat biopsies revealed 11 RCCs | |||
Shannon et al.[2008] | 235 | 51 (21.7%) | Inflammation/necrosis |
Connective tissue | |||
Vasudevan et al.[2006] | 100 | 30 (30%) | Fat tissue |
Wang et al.[2009] | 110 | 10 (9%) | Insufficient tissue |
2 nondiagnostic biopsies were renal cell cancer after nephrectomy |