Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 6;7(2):194–199. doi: 10.1007/s12539-015-0260-2

Table 1.

Leave-one-out prediction performances of the Echo algorithm compared with the other alternatives

Cutoff Sn Sp Ac MCC Cutoff Sn Sp Ac MCC
Echo GPS 2.1
MAPK3 2.66 0.6593 0.9598 0.9558 0.3321 High 0.6437 0.9537 0.9492 0.3104
2.22 0.9451 0.9214 0.9218 0.3485 Medium 0.9310 0.8939 0.8944 0.3027
2.2 0.9560 0.9198 0.9203 0.3492 Low 0.9425 0.8451 0.8464 0.2503
MAPK8 3 0.4848 0.9781 0.9658 0.4027 High 0.3056 0.9648 0.9497 0.2032
2.08 0.9697 0.9157 0.9170 0.4490 Medium 0.9444 0.9128 0.9135 0.4150
1.82 1.0000 0.9071 0.9094 0.4438 Low 0.9444 0.8574 0.8594 0.3264
CDK5 2.3 1.0000 0.9672 0.9678 0.5931 High 0.6316 0.9627 0.9568 0.3684
Medium 1.0000 0.9206 0.9220 0.4141
Low 1.0000 0.8651 0.8675 0.3205
EGFR 1.76 0.6909 0.9471 0.9159 0.6191 High 0.6393 0.9410 0.9056 0.5610
1.53 0.7818 0.9169 0.9004 0.6108 Medium 0.7377 0.8734 0.8574 0.4934
1.44 0.8727 0.8992 0.8960 0.6374 Low 0.7705 0.8013 0.7977 0.4268
SYK 1.5 0.6735 0.9440 0.9113 0.5970 High 0.5667 0.9386 0.9086 0.4543
1.3 0.9184 0.9188 0.9187 0.7064 Medium 0.8824 0.8910 0.8900 0.6289
1.24 0.9184 0.8936 0.8966 0.6559 Low 0.9020 0.8256 0.8349 0.5408
Met 0.94 1.0000 0.9505 0.9606 0.8930 High 0.9615 0.9223 0.9302 0.8126
Medium 1.0000 0.8252 0.8605 0.6983
Low 1.0000 0.7961 0.8372 0.6636
PKA_alpha 1.9030 0.7188 0.9804 0.9767 0.4870 High 0.6541 0.9769 0.9714 0.4534
1.8350 0.8125 0.9603 0.9582 0.4154 Medium 0.8054 0.9415 0.9391 0.3775
1.8100 0.9375 0.9388 0.9388 0.3957 Low 0.8946 0.9032 0.9030 0.3310
MAPK1 2.3426 0.8333 0.9592 0.9573 0.4264 High 0.7304 0.9533 0.9500 0.3561
2.0110 0.9250 0.9250 0.9250 0.3608 Medium 0.9130 0.8990 0.8992 0.3090
2.0096 0.9333 0.9249 0.9250 0.3639 Low 0.9304 0.8470 0.8482 0.2526
Abl 1.6458 0.6250 0.9447 0.9170 0.5234 High 0.4375 0.9170 0.8745 0.3164
1.6300 0.6458 0.9328 0.9079 0.5058 Medium 0.5208 0.8644 0.8339 0.2915
1.6000 0.6667 0.9308 0.9079 0.5155 Low 0.5833 0.7854 0.7675 0.2429
PKG 2.2300 0.5909 0.9877 0.9806 0.5141 High 0.5238 0.9866 0.9783 0.4554
2.2000 0.7273 0.9770 0.9726 0.5026 Medium 0.6190 0.9641 0.9579 0.3673
2.1000 0.7273 0.9659 0.9617 0.4352 Low 0.6905 0.9360 0.9316 0.3145
Aurror_A 1.3600 0.5517 0.9836 0.9719 0.5028 High 0.3214 0.9746 0.9573 0.2657
1.3000 0.6897 0.9326 0.9260 0.3641 Medium 0.5714 0.9317 0.9221 0.2956
1.2130 0.7586 0.9123 0.9082 0.3546 Low 0.6071 0.8888 0.8813 0.2417
ATM 1.7281 0.9123 0.9641 0.9633 0.4885 High 0.8246 0.9628 0.9607 0.4389
1.7157 1.0000 0.9628 0.9633 0.5238 Medium 0.9649 0.9474 0.9477 0.4413
1.7000 1.0000 0.9617 0.9623 0.5184 Low 0.9825 0.9443 0.9448 0.4381
Echo SUMOsp
SUMO 3.1838 0.9015 0.9965 0.9923 0.9084 Medium 0.8817 0.9260 0.9243 0.5060
2.038 0.9284 0.8879 0.8897 0.4731 Low 0.9247 0.8545 0.8572 0.3933
3.237 0.8925 0.9975 0.9928 0.9138 High 0.8065 0.9670 0.9609 0.6128
Echo GPS 3.0
Nitrated Y 1.9193 0.3125 0.9260 0.8833 0.2114 High 0.2889 0.9002 0.8257 0.1884
1.7 0.5521 0.8684 0.8464 0.2912 Medium 0.4053 0.8502 0.7960 0.2171
Low 0.5009 0.8018 0.7651 0.2335
S nitro 2.65 0.3202 0.9921 0.91289 0.48727 High 0.2520 0.9117 0.8040 0.1897
2 0.48276 0.94273 0.8885 0.44309 Medium 0.3532 0.8672 0.7833 0.2175
1.69 0.54187 0.83608 0.80139 0.30003 Low 0.5357 0.8014 0.7580 0.2864

The cutoff values of Echo are tuned to match the similar specificity levels of the alternative algorithms, and the four performance measurements are calculated for the Echo algorithm. The performances of the alternative algorithms are collected from the respective publications. Rows of “SUMO” are for SUMOylation, rows of “Nitrated Y” are for Nitrated tyrosine, and rows of “S nitro” are for S nitrosylation