Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 27;10(8):e0136023. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0136023

Table 2. Associations of clinicopathological variables with PD-1 (in TILs) or PD-L1 (in NSCLC cells).

Variables PD-1 (+) in TILs p-value* n (%) PD-L1 (+) in NSCLC p-value* n (%)
Age p-value 0.887 0.580
<70 years 47 (22%) 49 (23%)
≥70 years 25 (23%) 28 (26%)
Sex p-value 0.260 0.637
Male sex 60 (24%) 62 (25%)
Female sex 12 (17%) 15 (21%)
Smoking status p-value 0.384 0.315
Non-smoker 10 (16%) 18 (30%)
Smoker or ex-smoker 57 (23%) 57 (23%)
Performance status p-value 0.120 0.867
ECOG 0 18 (31%) 15 (25%)
ECOG ≥1 52 (21%) 61 (24%)
Adjuvant therapy p-value 0.849 0.712
No adjuvant therapy 61 (22%) 65 (24%)
Adjuvant therapy 11 (24%) 12 (26%)
Tumor stage p-value 0.498 0.508
Stage I 39 (21%) 42 (23%)
Stage ≥1I 33 (25%) 35 (26%)
Tumor size p-value 0.664 0.481
pT1 24 (24%) 21 (21%)
pT2-4 48 (22%) 56 (25%)
Lymph nodes status p-value 0.489 0.892
pN0 43 (21%) 48 (24%)
pN1-3 29 (25%) 29 (25%)
Tumor histology p-value 0.505 0.089
Squamous cell carcinoma 36 (21%) 48 (28%)
Non squamous cell carcinoma 36 (24%) 29 (20%)
Tumor grading p-value 1.000 0.786
< G2 25 (22%) 29 (25%)
≥ G2 44 (22%) 47 (24%)
Apoptosis p-value 0.523 0.162
Negative Bcl-2 expression 50 (22%) 52 (23%)
Positive Bcl-2 expression 19 (26%) 23 (31%)
p-value 0.464 0.013
Negative Bcl-xl expression 41 (21%) 36 (18%)
Positive Bcl-xl expression 25 (25%) 32 (32%)
EGFR mutation status p-value 0.288 1.000
No EGFR mutation 7 (32%) 8 (36%)
EGFR mutation 0 2 (33%)
Proliferation (ki-67) p-value 0.756 0.287
Negative ki-67 expression 16 (21%) 22 (29%)
Positive ki-67 expression 56 (23%) 55 (23%)
PD-1 expression in tumor Infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) p-value 1.000
negative lymphocytic expression 60 (24%)
negative lymphocytic expression 17 (24%)
PD-L1 expression in NSCLC p-value 1.000
negative tumor expression 55 (23%)
positive tumor expression 17 (22%)

*p values according to Fisher’s exact test.