Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 28;10(8):e0136539. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0136539

Table 2. Effectiveness of Influenza Vaccine for Children in 2013/14 Influenza Season (N = 4727).

Any Influenza e Type A e A(H1N1)pdm09 f Type B e
VE% (95% CI) VE% (95% CI) VE% (95% CI) VE% (95% CI)
All Ages 6 mo-15 y/o Crude 45 (38–51) (880/2281) [1303/2446]* 62 (55–68) (265/876) [1303/2446]* 77 (59–87) (17/66) [281/468]* 32 (22–40) (615/1405) [1303/2446]*
Adjusted a , b 45 (39–52) 63 (56–69) 77 (59–87) 26 (14–36)
Adjusted a , b , c 45 (38–52) 63 (56–69) 77 (59–88) 25 (13–35)
Adjusted a , b , d 51 (43–58) 67(59–74) 85 (65–93) 33 (20–45)
Age 6–11 m/o Crude 24 (-77-68) (8/49) [34/166] 29 (-82-73) (6/39) [34/166] NA g (0/2) [8/36] NA g (2/10) [34/166]
Adjusted a 21 (-87-67) 30 (-85-74) NA g NA g
Age 1–2 y/o Crude 61 (49–70) (114/342) [451/803] 70 (58–78) (63/224) [451/803] 67 (15–87) (8/21) [102/157] 41(12–60) (51/118) [451/803]
Adjusted a 63 (51–72) 72 (60–80) 67 (15–87) 41 (10–61)
Age 6 m/o-2 y/o Crude 55 (42–65) (122/391) [485/969] 65 (52–74) (69/263) [485/969] 60 (1–84) (8/23) [110/193] 30 (-2-52) (53/128) [485/969]
Adjusted a 57 (44–67) 67 (54–76) 62 (4–85) 29 (-6-52)
Age 3–5 y/o Crude 58 (48–67) (208/539) [406/675] 72 (62–80) (73/248) [406/675] 85 (44–96) (3/17) [78/134] 43 (24–57) (135/291) [406/675]
Adjusted a 60 (49–69) 73 (63–81) 84 (43–96) 44 (25–58)
Age 6–12 y/o Crude 36 (23–47) (495/1169) [371/694] 55 (41–66) (113/331) [371/694] 88 (64–96) (5/23) [85/123] 27 (11–40) (382/838) [371/694]
Adjusted a 39 (26–50) 58 (44–69) 90 (67–97) 30 (13–43)
Age 13–15 y/o Crude 29 (-17-57) (55/182) [41/108] 32 (-57-70) (10/34) [41/108] NA g (1/3) [8/18] 29 (-21-58) (45/148) [41/108]
Adjusted a 22 (-33-54) 12 (-115-64) NA g 23 (-34-56)

a Adjusted for comorbidity (yes or no, except H1N1 analysis), area (north area, middle area, south of the Kanto region), months of onset.

b Adjusted for age (0–15 y/o).

c Adjusted for time tested after the onset (<12, 12–48 and >48 hours).

d Patients tested only >12 hours after onset.

Data for 3046 patients were available; 1499 for any influenza (A; 537, H1N1; 43, B; 962) and 1547 for influenza negative.

e Two hospitals have no information on comorbidity.

f Only four institutes used IRDTs that can detect A(H1N1)pdm09. One hospital had no information on comorbidity.

g Not analyzed because few patients developed influenza.

* (vaccinated/cases) [vaccinated/controls].