Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Aug 28.
Published in final edited form as: Circ Res. 2015 Jul 9;117(6):558–575. doi: 10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.114.304792

TABLE 3.

Subgroup analysis to identify any impact of the type of ischemic heart disease, location of myocardial infarction, left ventricular ejection fraction at baseline, route of bone marrow cell transplantation, and methods of cell preparation on outcome variables.

Outcome Difference in mean (95% CI) BMC therapy (n) Control (n) Difference in mean (95% CI) BMC therapy (n) Control (n) P value for Interaction

Acute MI Chronic IHD
LVEF 2.49 (1.19, 3.79) 1065 832 3.84 (2.30, 5.38) 361 248 0.19
Infarct scar size −2.13 (−3.49, −0.78) 668 545 −5.90 (−8.03, −3.78) 56 25 0.003
LVESV −4.87 (−7.29, −2.45) 713 567 −10.37 (−18.56, −2.18) 222 144 0.21
LVEDV −2.55 (−5.00, −0.10) 718 572 −1.84 (−9.13, 5.46) 201 129 0.86

Anterior Wall MI MI in Other Territories
LVEF 2.04 (0.18, 3.89) 497 373 3.13 (1.79, 4.47) 833 644 0.35
Infarct scar size −1.90 (−3.72, −0.07) 311 258 −3.04 (−5.70, −0.38) 369 280 0.49
LVESV −5.57 (−9.34, −1.81) 294 225 −7.34 (−12.52, −2.16) 516 390 0.59
LVEDV −9.57 (−16.50, −2.63) 272 218 −1.48 (−3.04, 0.08) 518 397 0.03

Baseline LVEF <41 % Baseline LVEF ≥41%
LVEF 2.85 (1.34, 4.35) 602 454 2.97 (1.63, 4.31) 824 626 0.90
Infarct scar size −2.16 (−3.97, −0.34) 265 217 −2.38 (−4.76, 0.00) 449 343 0.88
LVESV −9.42 (−14.53, −4.32) 369 287 −4.70 (−7.40, −1.99) 566 424 0.11
LVEDV −3.79 (−7.60, 0.02) 348 272 −1.60 (−6.12, 2.91) 571 429 0.47

Baseline LVEF <50 % Baseline LVEF ≥50 %
LVEF 3.03 (1.94, 4.11) 1240 910 2.77 (0.86, 4.69) 206 170 0.82
Infarct scar size −2.84 (−4.24, −1.45) 832 702 −0.72 (−3.63, 2.19) 84 67 0.20
LVESV −7.24 (−10.31, −4.17) 770 565 −3.43 (−7.69, 0.84) 165 146 0.15
LVEDV −4.38 (−7.88, −0.87) 777 578 1.66 (−4.02, 7.34) 165 146 0.08

IC - CIHD IM - CIHD
LVEF 2.37 (0.38, 4.37) 199 151 4.12 (2.33, 5.92) 238 164 0.20
Infarct scar size −3.02 (−7.67, 1.64) 70 48 −5.90 (−16.36, 4.56) 80 55 0.62
LVESV −4.86 (−11.15, 1.44) 74 43 −11.95 (−23.04, −0.86) 202 136 0.28
LVEDV 1.61 (−5.12, 8.34) 74 43 −5.37 (−17.71, 6.98) 127 93 0.33

Other Ficoll-based methods Lymphoprep
LVEF 2.93 (1.66, 4.20) 1167 894 2.31 (−0.08, 4.69) 148 137 0.65
Infarct scar size −1.47 (−3.37, 0.42) 389 300 −1.67 (−4.56, 1.22) 136 126 0.91
LVESV −6.45 (−9.91, −2.99) 641 504 −6.46 (−8.88, −4.05) 69 62 1.00
LVEDV −4.21 (−7.97, −0.45) 641 504 −9.54 (−27.93, 8.85) 69 62 0.58

No Heparin Heparinized saline
LVEF 1.75 (0.54, 2.96) 680 431 5.15 (3.17, 7.12) 347 321 0.004
Infarct scar size −0.49 (−2.74, 1.75) 275 165 −3.89 (−5.96, −1.82) 202 190 0.03
LVESV −3.74 (−6.30, −1.18) 429 295 −7.62 (−12.20, −3.04) 260 233 0.15
LVEDV −4.40 (−9.94, 1.14) 413 285 −1.87 (−3.95, 0.22) 260 233 0.40

Abbreviations: CIHD, chronic ischemic heart disease; LVEDV, left ventricular end-diastolic volume; LVEF, left ventricular ejection fraction; LVESV, left ventricular end-systolic volume; IC, intracoronary; IM, intramuscular; MI, myocardial infarction; BM, Bone marrow