Positron Emission Tomography (PET) |
A radioactive ligand is administered intravenously to index DA release or receptor binding |
Metabolic increases or decreases measured in discrete brain regions of interest where the ligand has bound |
Responsivity of the DA system is directly measured |
Poor spatial resolution as compared to fMRI; poor temporal resolution; complex procedure is ethically challenging when used with vulnerable populations |
No |
MR-spectroscopy |
Single or multiple voxels are targeted for neurochemical examination in an MR environment |
Levels of neurochemicals are measured; these reflect cellular processes involved in energy expenditure |
Relative ease of data collection; non-invasive; impairments at the cellular level can be assessed in the living brain |
Difficult to examine whole-brain; resolution limited at low field strengths; only chemicals present in large concentrations can be measured |
Yes |
Structural MRI |
Whole-brain or regional brain volumes are measured |
White matter volumes, indices of white matter connectivity, and gray matter volumes in areas known to be innervated by DA |
Relative ease of data collection; non-invasive |
Links between structure and function are indirect and unclear in relation to neurochemical function |
Yes |
Functional MRI |
Whole-brain or regional brain activations are measured through blood-oxygenation-level-Dependent (BOLD) signals during a behavioral task or at rest |
Activations are measured in areas known to be innervated by DA; these activations can be provoked through the use of well-designed behavioral probes |
Ease of data collection; non-invasive; use of behavioral probes in the scanner allows function to be directly linked to neural signals |
BOLD signal cannot resolve increases or decreases in activation at the neurochemical level; interpretation is challenging |
Yes |
Pharmacological Challenge During fMRI or PET |
Individuals systemically ingest drugs that activate (agonists) or inhibit (antagonists) DA release or receptor activity; can be combined with fMRI or PET |
Behavioral functions typically compared pre-versus post-ingestion; some recent studies combine with neuroimaging to index brain function following drug challenge |
Probes can be utilized that have selective effects on various aspects of DA synthesis or receptor function; many treatment applications |
Most studies are conducted under acute challenge conditions; long-range effects of drug ingestion less well-studied; systemic administration has poor specificity for regional brain effects |
No |