5. Vector density: ITNs versus no intervention.
Trial ID | Unit of randomization | Intervention | Main vector | Measure (method) | Pre‐intervention | Post‐intervention | Effect measure (95% CI) or P value | ||
ITNs | Control | ITNs | Control | ||||||
Chowdhury 2011 BGD | Cluster of 50 houses | PermaNet® 2.0 (deltamethrin 55mg/m²) distributed to all households in November 2006. | P. argentipes | Total sandflies (monthly collections from 40 houses using light traps). |
724 (October 2006) | 683 (October 2006) | 18 (January 2007) 361 (March 2007) |
54 (January 2007) 1219 (March 2007) |
RR 0.73 (0.23 to 2.25) (Jan 2007) RR 0.31 (0.21 to 0.46) (Mar 2007) The benefit with ITNs was still present at 12 months |
Emami 2009 IRN | City sector (approx. 3000 houses) | Olyset® (permethrin 2%) distributed to all households in August 2004. | P. sergenti | Total sandflies (monthly collections during transmission season using light traps and sticky traps). |
Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported | The authors state: 'There were statistically significant differences in the monthly catches of P. sergenti between control and intervention sectors in both cities (P < 0.05)'. |
Joshi 2009 ASIA | Hamlets or neighnourhoods | PermaNet® (deltamethrin 55mg/m²) distributed to all households (date not stated). | P. argentipes | Mean number of sandflies per per house (light traps) per night at all sites pooled in Nepal, Bangladesh and India. | 9.92 (date not stated) |
9.41 (date not stated) |
8.32 (5 months post intervention) |
12.15 (5 months post intervention) |
Pre‐intervention P = 0.798 Post‐intervention P = 0.16 (The trial authors state the effect was significant in India and Bangladesh but not Nepal) |
Abbreviations: IRN = Iran; BGD = Bangladesh; ITNs = insecticide treated nets; RR = risk ratio).