Table 1.
Study | Sample: n (mean), years, age range | Diagnosis | Assessment of depression | Results on prevalence rates of depression | Risk factors and explicative hypotheses |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gillberg and Billstedt (2000) [7] |
n = 35 (age: DK) Range: children and adolescents with autism |
ASD | Review of the literature | 33% had an additional psychiatric disorder, with depression being the most common diagnosis | Biological factors: comorbid conditions may be markers for underlying pathophysiology |
| |||||
Whitehouse et al. (2009) [10] |
n = 35 AS (age: 14.2) Range: 12–17.6 CG: n = 35 NT (age: 14.4) Range: 13.2–16.10 |
HFASD | CES-DC (Centre for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale) | 33% self-reported significantly higher levels of depressive symptoms than the NT population | Social support: quality of social relationships |
| |||||
Kanner (1943) [11] |
n = 11 (age: 5.4) Range: 2.4–11 |
ASD | DK | One showed tendency towards depression. | Social support: quality of social relationships |
| |||||
Wing (1981) [12] |
n = 34 (age: DK) Range: 5–35 |
HFASD | DK | The most common psychiatric diagnosis was depression (10 subjects: approximately) | Age; cognitive level, capacity for introspection, awareness of deficits (insight), and alexithymia; life events and effects brought about by character came from the domain of repetitive and restricted behaviours |
| |||||
Ghaziuddin et al. (1998) [13] |
n = 35 (age: 15) Range: 8–51 |
HFASD | K–SADS–E (Kiddie-Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia-Epidemiological Version) | 65% had an additional psychiatric disorder, with depression being the most common (37%) | Histories of first-degree relatives and environmental context |
| |||||
Kanne et al. (2009) [14] |
n = 177 (age: 7.3) Range: 3–18 CG: their siblings (n = 148) |
Autism | CBCL (Child Behaviour Checklist) C-TRF (Caregiver/Teacher Report Form) |
26% presented depression | Cognitive level; histories of first-degree relatives environmental context |
| |||||
Barnhill and Myles (2001) [15] |
n = 33 AS (age: 15) Range: 12–17 |
HFASD | CDI (Children's Depression Inventory) | 54% showed depressive symptoms | Cognitive level, capacity for introspection, awareness of deficits (insight), and alexithymia |
| |||||
Leyfer et al. (2006) [16] |
n = 109 (age: 9.2) Range: 5–17 |
Autism | ACI-PL (Autism Comorbidity Interview-Present and Lifetime Version): this is a modification on the Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia | 13% major depression | Biological factors: comorbidity |
| |||||
Mayes et al. (2011) [17] |
n = 627 (age: 6.6) Range: 1–17 |
ASD (64.4% HFASD) | PBS (Pediatric Behaviour Scale) | The maternal descriptions indicated depression in 72% of the HFASD cases | Gender; age; cognitive level, capacity for introspection, awareness of deficits (insight), and alexithymia; social support: quality of social relationships |
| |||||
Mayes et al. (2011) [18] |
n = 233 (age: 8.3) Range: 6–16 |
HFASD (IQ > 79) | PBS | 54% of the mothers reported depression in their children | Age; cognitive level, capacity for introspection, awareness of deficits (insight), and alexithymia |
| |||||
Green et al. (2000) [19] |
n = 20 AS (age: 13.75) Range: 11–19 CG: n = 20 (age: 14.47) Range: 11–19 |
HFASD | ICD-10 (Tenth Revision of the International Classification of Disease) | Higher levels of depression than in the CG. Although only 5% satisfied criteria for major depression, 40% showed chronic unhappiness and 55%, irritability | Biological factors: comorbidity |
| |||||
Hurtig et al. (2009) [20] |
n = 43 AS or HFA (age: 13) Range: 11–17 GC: n = 217 (age: 13.5) |
HFASD | YSR (Youth Self-Report) CBCL (Child Behaviour Checklist) TRF (Teacher Report Form) |
33% self-reported significantly higher levels of depressive symptoms than the NT population | Gender |
| |||||
Kim et al. (2000) [21] |
n = 59 (19 AS; 40 HFASD) (age: 12) Range: 9–14 CG: n = 1751 Range: 9–14 |
HFASD | OCHS-R (Ontario Child Health Study-Revised) | 17% significant clinical symptomatology of depression | Biological factors: comorbidity |
| |||||
Meyer et al. (2006) [22] |
n = 31 AS age: 10.1 Range: 8–14 CG: n = 33 NT |
HFASD | BASC-SRP (Behaviour Assessment System for Children-Self Report of Personality) BASC-PRS (Behaviour Assessment System for Children-Parent Report Scale) |
Self-reported symptoms of depression higher than in CG | Cognitive level, capacity for introspection, awareness of deficits (insight), and alexithymia |
| |||||
Brereton et al. (2006) [23] |
n = 381/367 ASD (age: 7.4) Range: 3.8–24 GC: n = 581 intellectual disability without ASD |
ASD | DBC-P (Developmental Behaviour Checklist) | Parents offered significantly higher scores for behaviour problems, anxiety, depression, and irritability compared with normality, as well as higher degrees of anxiety, behaviour problems, depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder than in CG | Gender; age |
ASD: Autism Spectrum Disorder; AS: Asperger Syndrome; CG: control group; HFASD: high functioning autism spectrum disorder (IQ > 70); NT: neurotypical.
DK: it indicates that the symptom/sign was not discussed in the paper, not that the authors were unable to assess it.