Table 1.
Study (year) | Case | Control | CA199 | CA242 | CEA | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||||||
Method | Cutoff | TP/FP/FN/TN | Method | Cutoff | TP/FP/FN/TN | Method | Cutoff | TP/FP/FN/TN | |||
Wang L (2000) [9] | 130 | B | ELISA | 37 | 40/27/5/58 | ELISA | 21 | 37/34/8/51 | ELISA | 3.2 | 32/61/13/24 |
Liu CM (2004) [10] | 74 | H | ELISA | 37 | 26/6/7/34 | ELISA | 20 | 24/5/10/35 | ELISA | 5 | 14/7/20/33 |
Cui LH (2008) [11] | 74 | B | ELISA | 35 | 30/4/10/30 | ELISA | 20 | 28/5/12/29 | ELISA | 5 | 24/6/16/28 |
Dong AP (2009) [12] | 165 | B/H | RIA | 37 | 45/24/9/86 | RIA | 20 | 44/26/11/84 | RIA | 10 | 36/36/19/74 |
Wang P (2003) [13] | 64 | B | CLIA | 60 | 30/4/12/18 | ELISA | 20 | 29/6/13/16 | CLIA | 5 | 20/2/22/20 |
Li XM (2014) [14] | 249 | H | CLIA | 37 | 90/17/39/103 | ELISA | 20 | 83/28/46/92 | CLIA | 5 | 54/41/75/79 |
Yang YC (2007) [15] | 244 | B | ELISA | 37 | 134/20/39/51 | ELISA | 20 | 110/17/63/54 | ELISA | 5 | 53/6/120/65 |
Cheng J (2012) [16] | 466 | B/H | CLIA | 35 | 171/6/94/195 | CLIA | 20 | 150/3/115/198 | CLIA | 5 | 102/7/163/194 |
Li XM (2013) [17] | 229 | H | CLIA | 35 | 88/21/21/99 | ELISA | 20 | 78/19/31/101 | CLIA | 5 | 47/37/62/83 |
Li N (2001) [18] | 123 | B | CLIA | 35 | 50/23/13/37 | CLIA | 20 | 47/10/16/50 | CLIA | 5 | 27/12/36/48 |
Lu C (2005) [19] | 95 | B/H | CLIA | 37 | 31/16/7/41 | CLIA | 20 | 30/9/8/48 | CLIA | 5 | 23/22/15/35 |
Xia F (2006) [20] | 138 | B | CLIA | 35 | 58/8/23/49 | CLIA | 20 | 59/6/22/51 | CLIA | 5 | 50/10/31/47 |
Li FM (2010) [21] | 125 | B | ECLIA | 35 | 38/22/7/58 | ECLIA | 10 | 32/9/13/71 | ECLIA | 10 | 15/15/30/65 |
You YQ (2012) [22] | 100 | B | ECLIA | 37 | 39/21/11/29 | ECLIA | 25 | 40/18/10/22 | ECLIA | 5 | 21/19/29/31 |
Liao Q (2007) [23] | 150 | B | ELISA | 37 | 84/15/28/23 | ELISA | 20 | 66/10/46/28 | ELISA | 5 | 37/2/75/36 |
Zhang LZ (2008) [24] | 160 | B | CLIA | 37 | 71/9/24/56 | ELISA | 20 | 71/5/24/60 | CLIA | 10 | 40/8/55/57 |
Yan H (2005) [25] | 98 | H | CLIA | 35 | 56/6/10/26 | CLIA | 20 | 52/5/14/27 | CLIA | 5 | 45/8/21/24 |
Gao YC (2005) [26] | 496 | B | CLIA | 37 | 236/71/79/110 | RIA | 20 | 222/52/93/129 | CLIA | 10 | 74/7/241/174 |
Huang BX (2011) [27] | 75 | B | CLIA | 37 | 37/4/8/26 | CLIA | 20 | 28/7/17/23 | CLIA | 10 | 18/6/27/24 |
Zhang M (2005) [28] | 146 | H | MEIA | 37 | 38/21/8/79 | MEIA | 20 | 35/11/11/89 | MEIA | 5 | 12/20/34/80 |
Jiang A (2011) [29] | 96 | H | ECLIA | 35 | 39/12/9/36 | ECLIA | 20 | 34/11/14/37 | ECLIA | 5 | 22/13/26/35 |