Table 1.
Studies | Design | Populations (complete data) | Lesions | Imaging | Cerebellar outcomes |
Developmental outcomes | Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bednarek [24] | Retrospective case series |
6 PT 24–28 w GA with CBI | CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS | Presence of CBI | Heterogeneous evaluation and variable time |
6/6 (100 %) PT children with CBI presented with adverse outcome: 3 died and 3 had impaired neurological development. |
Dyet [28] | Prospective cohort |
119 PT <30 w GA | CBI, cerebral injury |
ptMRI and tMRI | Presence of CBI | 18–36 months: Griffiths Mental Developmental Scales, CP |
6/8 (75 %) PT children with CBI presented with adverse outcome: 3 died and 3 had severe developmental delay including 1 with CP. |
Johnsen [32] | Retrospective case series |
67 PT <28 w GA, ≤1,000 g with CP |
CBI, cerebral injury |
Follow-up MRI | Presence of CBI | 1.5–20 years Neurological status at clinical follow-up |
PT born subjects with CBI were more unlikely to walk (59 %) or talk (77 %) than those with a normal CBL (24 % and 19 %). |
Limperopoulos [22] |
Retrospective case–control |
35 PT ≤32 w GA with isolated CBI, 35 controls PT ≤32 w with no CBI or cerebral injury, 16 PT with CBI + cerebral injury |
CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS, follow-up MRI for PT with an abnor- mal HUS |
Presence of isolated CBI or combined CBI with cerebral injury |
2–5 years: Neuro exam MSEL PDMS VABS CBCL M-CHAT SCQ |
Isolated CBI was significantly associated with severe developmental delay in motor skills (40–54 %), language (37–40 %), and cognition (40–46 %); deficits in daily living activities performance (40 %), internalizing behavioral problems (34 %) and autistic features (37 %). Cerebral injury and more extended cerebellar lesions (bilateral vs unilateral) were associated with greater deficits. Vermal injury was associated with socialization difficulties (VABS) and positive autism screening (M-CHAT+SCQ). |
Limperopoulos [26] |
Prospective cohort |
40 PT ≤32 w GA with isolated CBI |
CBI | HUS, follow-up MRI |
Regional cerebral volume contralateral to CBI |
18–63 months: Neuro exam MSEL PDMS CBCL M-CHAT |
Greater dorsolateral prefrontal volume was associated with better M-CHAT and CBCL internalizing scores. Greater sensorimotor volume was associated with higher PDMS gross motor score. Greater premotor volume was associated with higher Mullen cognitive scores. Greater midtemporal volume was associated with higher Mullen Expressive language score. |
Mercuri [11] | Retrospective case series |
10 PT ≤33 w GA with CBI | CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS, follow-up MRI |
Presence of CBI | 7 month–8 years: Neuro exam, motor development |
All PT children with CBI had mild (40 %) to severe (60 %) motor delay. |
Messerchmidt [23] |
Retrospective case–control |
31 PT ≤31 w GA with severe volume reduction in CBL on HUS; 31 PT GA and gender matched with cerebral injury but normal CBL on HUS |
CBL volume reduction, cerebral injury |
HUS | Presence of CBI | 24–36 months: Neuro exam BSID-II: Motor + cognitive composites |
PT children with CBI had significantly worse neurodevelopmental outcomes than children without CBI. All children with CBI (100 %) had CP and had neurodevelopmental delay (motor and cognitive). |
Steggerda [9] | Prospective cohort |
108 PT <32 w GA | CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS, tMRI | Presence of small CBI |
2 years: Neuro exam GMFCS BSID-III: Motor + cognitive composites CBCL |
In PT infants with small CBI, behavioral problems were found in 15–23 %, motor delay in 15 %and mild or severe neurodevelopmental outcome in 61.5 %. None of the children with small CBI had cognitive delay. Small CBI was not significantly associated with poorer neurodevelopmental outcomes or problematic behavior when compared to preterm without CBI. |
Tam [29] | Prospective cohort |
94 PT ≤34 w GA | CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS, ptMRI & tMRI |
Presence of CBI | 3–6 years: Neuro exam WPPSI-III (IQ) |
Of the 8 PT infants with CBI detectable on MRI only, 4 (50 %) presented with abnormal neurological examination findings at 3–6 years of age. CBI was significantly associated with neurological anomalies, but not with IQ evaluated at follow-up. |
Van Kooji [30] | Prospective cohort |
112 PT <31 w GA | CBI, cerebral injury |
tMRI, | Presence of CBI, CBL volume and H1-MRS |
2 years: BSID-III: Motor + cognitive composites |
No significant differences in BSID-III scores between PT children with and without CBI. Cognitive scores were associated with CBL volume and CBL NAA/Cho ratio but not CBI. No significant association was found between CBL variables and the motor composite. |
Zafeiriou [31] | Retrospective case series |
12 PT <28 w GA with pontocerebellar hypoplasia |
Pontocerebellar hypoplasia, cerebral injury |
Follow-up MRI | Presence of pontocerebellar hypoplasia |
21–90 months: Neuro exam, motor development |
All PT children with pontocerebellar hypoplasia (100 %) had CP and presented with movement disorders. |
Zayek [25] | Retrospective cohort |
1120 PT <28 w GA | CBI, cerebral injury |
HUS | Presence of CBI | 12–18 months: BSID-II or BSID-III: Motor + cognitive composites |
PT infants with CBI had significantly more neurodevelopmental impairments. Of the 32 children with CBI, 15 (50 %) had cognitive impairment, 18 (56 %) motor impairment including CP in 10 (32 %). Lesions isolated to the cerebellar hemispheres were associated with lower cognitive scores, but not with motor skills. Lesions involving the vermis were associated with motor and cognitive impairments. |
BSID Bayley Scale for Infant Development, CBCL Child Behavior Checklist, CBI cerebellar injury, CBL cerebellum, CP cerebral palsy, GA gestational age, H1 -MRS proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy, HUS head ultra sound, M-CHAT Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers, MSEL Mullen Scales for Early Learning, PDMS Peabody Developmental Motor Scales, PT preterm, ptMRI preterm MRI, SCQ Social Communication Questionnaire, tMRI term or term-equivalent MRI, VABS Vineland Adaptative Behavior Scale, w week, WPPSI Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence