| Ref (type) | Population | Outcome, Interventions | Results and statistical analysis | Effect size | Favours |
| Complications of surgery – adverse events short-term (intraoperative and immediate postoperative) | |||||
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 4 RCTs in this analysis |
Sepsis
18/345 (5%) with endometrial resection/ablation 88/276 (32%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.19 95% CI 0.12 to 0.31 P <0.00001 |
Large effect size | endometrial resection/ablation |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 3 RCTs in this analysis |
Haemorrhage
10/310 (3%) with endometrial resection/ablation 13/245 (5%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.69 95% CI 0.32 to 1.46 P = 0.33 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 4 RCTs in this analysis |
Blood transfusion
3/409 (1%) with endometrial resection/ablation 16/342 (5%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.20 95% CI 0.07 to 0.59 P = 0.0032 |
Large effect size | endometrial resection/ablation |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 3 RCTs in this analysis |
Pyrexia
9/298 (3%) with endometrial resection/ablation 53/307 (17%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.17 95% CI 0.09 to 0.35 P <0.00001 |
Large effect size | endometrial resection/ablation |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 5 RCTs in this analysis |
Vault haematoma
2/428 (1%) with endometrial resection/ablation 29/430 (7%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.11 95% CI 0.04 to 0.34 P = 0.000099 |
Large effect size | endometrial resection/ablation |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Wound haematoma
0/105 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 14/97 (14%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.03 95% CI 0.00 to 0.53 P = 0.016 |
Large effect size | endometrial resection/ablation |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Anaesthetic (not further defined)
0/105 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 2/97 (2%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.18 95% CI 0.01 to 3.80 P = 0.27 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 3 RCTs in this analysis |
Fluid overload
18/304 (6%) with endometrial resection/ablation 1/307 (1%) with hysterectomy |
RR 9.27 95% CI 2.17 to 39.64 P = 0.0027 |
Large effect size | hysterectomy |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 2 RCTs in this analysis |
Perforation
4/215 (2%) with endometrial resection/ablation 0/215 (0%) with hysterectomy |
RR 5.05 95% CI 0.61 to 42.16 P = 0.13 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Gastrointestinal obstruction/ileus
1/105 (1%) with endometrial resection/ablation 2/97 (2%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.46 95% CI 0.04 to 5.01 P = 0.53 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 2 RCTs in this analysis |
Laparotomy
2/194 (1%) with endometrial resection/ablation 5/189 (3%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.39 95% CI 0.08 to 1.97 P = 0.25 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Cystotomy
0/110 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 2/118 (2%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.21 95% CI 0.01 to 4.42 P = 0.32 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding 2 RCTs in this analysis |
Cervical laceration
2/199 (1%) with endometrial resection/ablation 0/210 (0%) with hysterectomy |
RR 3.16 95% CI 0.33 to 30.10 P = 0.32 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Cardiorespiratory event
0/110 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 3/118 (3%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.15 95% CI 0.01 to 2.93 P = 0.21 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Thromboembolic event
0/110 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 2/118 (2%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.21 95% CI 0.01 to 4.42 P = 0.32 |
Not significant | |
|
Systematic review |
Women of reproductive years with heavy menstrual bleeding Data from 1 RCT |
Re-admission/return to surgery
0/110 (0%) with endometrial resection/ablation 3/118 (3%) with hysterectomy |
RR 0.15 95% CI 0.01 to 2.93 P = 0.21 |
Not significant | |
| Pain | |||||
|
Systematic review |
Premenopausal women 2 RCTs in this analysis |
Surgery pain score
with hysterectomy with endometrial ablation Absolute results not reported |
MD 2.5 95% CI 2.2 to 2.9 P <0.0001 |
Effect size not calculated | endometrial ablation |