Table 5.
Author | Year | Intervention | Time before extubation | Intervention group | Control group | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Outcome parameter | Number | Percentage | Outcome parameter | Number | Percentage | P value | ||||
Darmon et al. [12] | 1992 | Dexamethasone 8 mg i.v. | 1 hour | Laryngeal edema | 11/327 | 3.4 % | Laryngeal edema | 17/337 | 5.0 % | ns |
Ho et al. [17] | 1996 | Hydrocortisone 100 mg i.v. | 1 hour | Laryngeal edema | 7/39 | 17.9 % | Laryngeal edema | 10/38 | 26.3 % | ns |
Cheng et al. [16] | 2006 | Methylprednisolone 40 mg i.v. | 24 hours | Stridor | 5/43 | 11.6 % | Stridor | 13/43 | 30.2 % | 0.15 |
Reintubation | 3/43 | 6.9 % | Reintubation | 11/43 | 25.6 % | NA | ||||
Methylprednisolone 4 × 40 mg i.v. | 24 hours | Stridor | 3/42 | 7.1 % | Stridor | 13/43 | 30.2 % | 0.005 | ||
Reintubation | 7/42 | 16.7 % | Reintubation | 11/43 | 25.6 % | NA | ||||
François et al. [11] | 2007 | Methylprednisolone 3 × 20 mg i.v. | 12 hours | Laryngeal edema | 11/355 | 3.1 % | Laryngeal edema | 76/343 | 22. % | <0.01 |
Reintubation | 13/355 | 3.7 % | Reintubation | 36/343 | 10.5 % | 0.02 | ||||
Lee et al. [30]a | 2007 | Dexamethasone 4 × 5 mg i.v. | 48 hours | Stridor | 4/40 | 10 % | Stridor | 11/40 | 27.5 % | 0.037 |
Reintubation | 1/40 | 2.5 % | Reintubation | 2/40 | 5.0 % | 0.56 | ||||
Cheng et al. [26]b | 2011 | Methylprednisolone 40 mg i.v. | 4 hours | Stridor | 6/38 | 15.8 % | Stridor | 13/33 | 39.4 % | 0.025 |
Reintubation | 3/38 | 7.9 % | Reintubation | 10/33 | 30.3 % | NA | ||||
Abbasi et al. [29] | 2014 | Budesonide 4 × 1 mg nebulized | 48 hours | Respiratory distress | 3/35 | 8.6 % | Respiratory distress | 11/35 | 31.4 % | 0.017 |
Stridor | 3/35 | 8.6 % | Stridor | 7/35 | 20 % | 0.17 | ||||
Reintubation | 3/35 | 8.6 % | Reintubation | 11/35 | 31.4 % | 0.017 |
i.v. intravenous, ns not significant, NA not applicable
aOnly patients with cuff leak volume (CLV) <110 ml were included. In patients with CLV ≥110 ml, stridor was found in 4.9 % of patients, and 1.4 % of patients were reintubated
bOnly patients with cuff leak percentage (CLP) <24 % were included. In patients with CLP ≥24 %, stridor was found in 3.8 % of patients, and intubation was performed in 5 % of patients