Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 23;10(9):e0138511. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138511

Table 1. Study, exposure, and outcome characteristics (N = 333 articles).

Variable Groups No. of articles reporting % of articles reporting
Total number of articles 333 100.0%
Sample size range (N participants) 39–100 36 10.8%
101–200 84 25.2%
201–300 63 18.9%
301–1,000 92 27.6%
1,001–48,924 58 17.4%
Year of publication 1983–2000 38 11.4%
2001–2005 71 21.3%
2006–2010 128 38.4%
2011-September 2013 96 28.8%
Type of publication Academic journal 261 78.4%
Dissertation/Thesis/Evaluation report 70 21.0%
Book chapter 2 0.6%
Country United States 271 81.4%
United Kingdom 9 2.7%
Australia 9 2.7%
Canada 7 2.1%
The Netherlands 6 1.8%
Finland 5 1.5%
Israel 4 1.2%
Norway 4 1.2%
Spain 3 0.9%
Portugal 3 0.9%
New Zealand 2 0.6%
Barbados 2 0.6%
Other (1 article per country/ region) 8 2.4%
Sampling procedure Non-representative 222 66.7%
Representative 102 30.6%
Other/Not reported 9 2.7%
Data type Cross-sectional 299 89.8%
Longitudinal 30 9.0%
Other 4 1.2%
Exposure instrument name * Schedule of Racist Events (SRE) 34 10.2%
Racism and Life Experience Scales (RaLES) 20 6.0%
Experiences of Discrimination (EOD) 19 5.7%
Perceived Racism Scale (PRS) 19 5.7%
Everyday Discrimination Scale (EDS)** 14 4.2%
Perceived Ethnic Discrimination Questionnaire (PEDQ) 10 3.0%
Multidimensional Inventory of Black Identity (MIBI): public regard subscale 10 3.0%
Nadanolitization scale 5 1.5%
Exposure number of items * Single item/s 56 16.8%
2–8 items 117 35.1%
9 or more 162 48.6%
Not reported 19 5.7%
Exposure Cronbach Alpha * 0.79 or lower 47 14.1%
0.80 or higher 162 48.6%
Not reported 77 23.1%
Mixed (instruments including subscales from both levels) 10 3.0%
Not applicable (single items) 56 16.8%
Exposure type * Direct 266 79.9%
Indirect (e.g., group, vicarious, proxy) 60 18.0%
Internalized 10 3.0%
Mixed (instruments including subscales from both levels) 12 3.6%
Not Reported 4 1.2%
Timeframe of Racism Exposure * Last month 12 3.6%
Last 12 months (includes last 6) 55 16.5%
Last >12 months and < 3 years 10 3.0%
Last 3 years–lifetime 47 14.1%
Not specified 210 63.1%
Mixed (instruments including subscales from both levels) 15 4.5%
Outcomes–negative mental health * Depression 124 37.2%
Psychological stress 71 21.3%
Distress 61 18.3%
Anxiety 48 14.4%
Negative affect 25 7.5%
PTSD and PTS 16 4.8%
Somatization 13 3.9%
Internalizing 12 3.6%
Suicidal ideation, planning, attempts 12 3.6%
General mental health 12 3.6%
Other mental health symptoms (e.g., paranoia, psychoticism) 12 3.6%
Outcomes–positive mental health * Self esteem 81 24.3%
Life satisfaction 28 8.4%
Control/Mastery 19 5.7%
Wellbeing 10 3.0%
Positive affect 4 1.2%
Outcomes–physical health * Blood pressure & Hypertension 24 7.2%
Overweight (BMI, WC, WHR, overweight, obesity) 17 5.1%
Heart conditions/illnesses 8 2.4%
Diabetes 7 2.1%
Cholesterol 4 1.2%
Miscellaneous physical health 20 6.0%
Outcomes–general health * General health (unspecified/ physical & mental) 30 9.0%

* Note that numbers do not add to 100% due to articles reporting multiple exposure instrument and multiple outcomes

** Includes Major Discrimination, and instruments from the Detroit Area Study.