Table 1. Resting Metabolic Rate and Respiratory Quotient.
Author/year | Population/N | MG1 RQ2 | Measured mean RQ | RMR3 (REE) mean kcal/day | Primary outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alam et al12 2005 | Healthy women n=37 | 0.85 | 0.83 | MG session 1=1390 MG session 2=1390 DTC4 session 1=1278 DTC session 2=1235 |
Reproducibility and validity for RMR of the MG using the DTC as a reference. |
Compher et al13 2005 | Home nutrition support patients. n=24 | 0.85 | 0.77 | MG session 1=1302 MG session 2=1296 DTC (only 1 session)= 1446 |
Reproducibility of the MG in a clinical population compared with the DTC. |
Cooper et at21 | Healthy Adults n=38 | 0.85 | N/A | N/A | MedGem was not valid compared to the DTC. |
Fares et al20 2008 | Healthy adults. n=48 | 0.85 | N/A | MG =1489 GEM=1149 ** |
Validity and acceptability of MG for measurement of REE in older adults. |
Fields et al14 2006 | Healthy children. n=100 | 0.85 | N/A | MG =1452 ** DTC =1349 |
Assess the validity of the MG in children. |
Hlynsky et al15 2005 | Anorexia nervosa patients vs healthy adults n=27 | 0.85 | Anorexia=0.9 Healthy=0.78 |
MG anorexia =1243 MG healthy = 1398 DTC anorexia = 1369 DTC healthy = 1519 |
Compare the MG with the DTC to determine if the tests agree |
Reeves, et al16 2004 | Cancer Patients vs healthy adults n=35 | 0.85 | Cancer=0.71 Healthy=0.72 |
MG cancer=1351 * MG healthy=1258 VMax6 cancer=1526 VMax healthy=1371 |
Compare measurements of REE using the MG device and VMax in pts with cancer vs. healthy subjects. |
Rubenbauer et al17 2006 | Healthy adults. n=19 | 0.85 | REE=0.83 FEE7=0.87 AEE8=0.88 |
MG REE=1551 Physiodyne REE=1552 MG FEE=1825 Physiodyne FEE=1875 MG AEE=3489 Physiodyne AEE=3333 |
Determine how closely the MG compared with the Physiodyne in 3 different physiologic conditions. |
Stewart et al18 2005 | Healthy adults n=50 | 0.85 | N/A | Mean difference in RMR=4.66±113.4 kcal/day | Compare simultaneous measurements of RMR with MG and DTC |
St-Onge, et al19 2004 | Healthy adults n=15 | 0.85 | N/A Food quotient provided was similar to RQ of MG |
MG REE=1543 DTC REE=1546 MG MEE9=1619 DTC MEE=1678 MG PE EE10=1630 DTC PE EE=1697 |
Determine if the MG can measure post-prandial energy expenditure compared with DTC |
MG = MedGem
RQ = Respiratory quotient
RMR (REE) = Resting metabolic rate (Resting energy expenditure)
DTC = Deltatrac
GEM = Europa Gas Exchange monitor
VMax = Vmax Encore 29
FEE = Fed energy expenditure
AEE = Activity energy expenditure
MEE = Measured energy expenditure
PP EE = Post-prandial energy expenditure
p<0.05 only for MG vs Vmax in patients with cancer
p<0.001