Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Sep 25.
Published in final edited form as: J Stat Comput Simul. 2014 Apr 14;85(9):1902–1916. doi: 10.1080/00949655.2014.907801

Table 2.

Simulation results for MAR scenarios with different missing patterns (independent and monotone) and different correlation structures (compound symmetry with low correlation, compound symmetry with medium correlation and first-order autoregressive (AR(1))) for p = 12 and n = 50.

Independent MAR Monotone MAR

PMSE MSE SENS SPEC PMSE MSE SENS SPEC
Low correlation: corr(Xi,j ,Xi,j′ ) = 0.1
Full-SPLS 14.45 3.33 94.8 75.7 14.66 3.54 95.3 70.5
CC-SPLS 27.27 12.69 78.7 59.2 33.38 14.95 72.5 56.3
SI-SPLS 18.03 6.61 89.3 68.0 19.66 8.19 84.0 66.0
MI-SPLS 16.52 4.93 98.0 38.7 17.18 5.72 95.0 44.3
Full-ENet 13.83 2.71 96.8 78.8 13.93 2.88 97.2 75.2
CC-ENet 26.83 12.82 64.5 92.0 31.14 15.20 58.8 91.5
SI-ENet 16.90 5.73 90.7 77.2 18.25 7.07 85.2 72.8
MI-ENet 16.38 5.07 92.8 74.7 16.88 5.70 90.0 75.5
SI-WENet 16.57 5.35 91.3 78.3 17.20 5.96 88.7 73.5
MI-WENet 15.96 4.74 93.5 76.5 16.41 5.23 89.8 73.7
Medium correlation: corr(Xi,j ,Xi,j′ ) = 0.5
Full-SPLS 32.28 7.24 90.5 34.5 32.77 7.67 89.0 38.0
CC-SPLS 40.92 16.02 81.3 40.2 49.39 19.42 79.8 38.2
SI-SPLS 35.15 9.57 80.7 45.0 35.49 9.47 81.3 41.5
MI-SPLS 34.69 8.83 91.5 30.8 34.88 8.69 90.7 34.3
Full-ENet 31.27 6.27 83.3 72.8 30.76 6.01 84.2 73.2
CC-ENet 53.89 27.42 47.5 91.3 58.18 28.58 43.8 88.8
SI-ENet 33.21 8.31 77.3 70.5 33.31 8.17 76.2 69.3
MI-ENet 32.72 7.79 78.2 69.0 32.22 7.20 77.5 68.2
SI-WENet 33.47 8.57 76.8 71.3 33.00 8.06 75.8 71.7
MI-WENet 32.63 7.66 78.8 69.0 31.94 6.99 78.2 67.8
AR(1) correlation: corr(Xi,j ,Xi,j′ ) = 0.8|j-j′ |
Full-SPLS 27.36 5.66 89.7 30.2 27.45 5.82 87.5 31.0
CC-SPLS 33.11 11.68 81.0 36.3 43.08 15.44 75.8 35.8
SI-SPLS 30.46 8.28 81.3 40.3 30.33 7.31 81.3 42.0
MI-SPLS 30.96 8.46 91.0 23.5 30.02 7.15 89.2 27.3
Full-ENet 26.91 5.19 78.5 66.8 26.59 5.04 78.5 70.5
CC-ENet 45.50 22.77 41.8 84.5 53.26 28.26 38.0 87.2
SI-ENet 30.21 8.30 67.8 70.5 28.28 6.68 69.3 72.2
MI-ENet 28.76 6.93 72.8 69.2 27.76 6.05 72.7 70.5
SI-WENet 28.81 7.01 70.3 67.5 27.95 6.37 69.0 72.0
MI-WENet 27.97 6.34 73.8 68.8 27.22 5.63 73.5 69.8