Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 16;61(Suppl 3):S179–S187. doi: 10.1093/cid/civ581

Table 3.

Revised Details and Definitions for Research Evaluation and Reporting Purposes

Entry criteria: Any current compatible symptom irrespective of duration in a child suspected to have tuberculosis; use the clinical features for clinical diagnosis or disease classification.
Clearly define inclusion criteria for research with careful documentation of presenting symptoms, contact history, and signs.
  • 1. Microbial confirmation

    Definition: At least 1 positive culture (with confirmed M. tuberculosis speciation) or 1 positive WHO-endorsed NAAT (eg, XpertMTB/RIF assay) from sputum (which could be sampled from expectorated sputum, induced sputum, nasopharyngeal aspirates, gastric aspirates, string tests, or other relevant intrathoracic samples) or stool.

  • 2. Clinical signs/symptoms suggestive of tuberculosis
    1. Persistent cough: persistent (>2 wk), unremitting cough.
    2. Weight loss/failure to thrive:
      1. Unexplained weight loss: >5% reduction in weight compared with the highest weight recorded in last 3 mo OR
      2. Failure to thrive
        1. Clear deviation from a previous growth trajectory, and/or
        2. Documented crossing of percentile lines in the preceding 3 mo, and/or
        3. Weight-for-age z score of ≤−2 in the absence of information on previous/recent growth trajectory, and/or
        4. Weight-for-height z score of ≤−2 in the absence of information on previous/recent growth trajectory AND
      3. Not responding to nutritional rehabilitation (or antiretroviral therapy if HIV infected)
    3. Persistent unexplained fever: Persistent (>1 wk) and unexplained fever (>38°C) reported by a guardian or objectively recorded at least once.
    4. Persistent, unexplained lethargy or reduced playfulness: persistent, unexplained lethargy or decrease in playfulness/activity reported by the parent/caregiver.
    5. Infants 0–60 d (or neonate): additionala signs and symptoms suggestive of tuberculosis include:
      1. neonatal pneumoniab or
      2. unexplained hepatosplenomegalyb or
      3. sepsis-like illnessb
  • 3. Interpretation of CXR
    1. CXR reading procedure
      1. CXR (2 views) will be read by a minimum of 2 independent and blinded readers who are experienced in reviewing CXRs in children.
      2. The overall quality of the CXR will be indicated
      3. In the case of discordant overall radiological classification, a third expert reader will be used and a final consensus achieved
    2. CXR reporting procedure
      1. Standardized forms with predetermined terminology to describe CXR abnormalities
      2. Essential radiological features with tick boxes used by experienced readers
      3. Predetermined Yes/No options for the CXR reader
    3. CXR is classified as “consistent with tuberculosis” if there is a positive response for any one of the radiographic features, at the same location, by at least 2 expert reviewers.
  • 4. Tuberculosis exposure
    1. History of exposure to M. tuberculosis: Reported exposure to a case of tuberculosis (household/close contact) within the preceding 12 mo:
      • - Documented (smear positive and/or culture positive, or tuberculosis treatment) OR
      • - Not documented but verbal report (smear positive and/or culture positive, or tuberculosis treatment)
  • 5. Immunological evidence of tuberculosis infection
    1. A positive tuberculin skin test (using 5TU PPD or 2TU PPD RT23) defined as:
      1. ≥10 mm if HIV uninfected
      2. ≥5 mm if HIV infected or severely malnourished OR
    2. A positive IGRA test
  • 6. Response to antituberculosis treatment
    1. Follow-up: All patients should be followed after initial evaluation, regardless of the initial disease classification or decision to treat for tuberculosis. Treatment other than antituberculosis treatment (eg, antibiotics for community-acquired pneumonia) and response to such treatment should be recorded.
    2. All patients should undergo clinical assessment and data collection 2 mo after baseline or after treatment initiation for those treated with antituberculosis treatment. Note that not all children with symptoms will receive antituberculosis treatment, and follow-up at 2 mo would be a useful time (in addition to earlier assessments) to assess resolution of symptoms without antituberculosis treatment and/or clinical response to alternative therapy (if any)
    3. Additional suggested data collection time points
      1. 2 wk after baseline or after treatment initiation for those treated with antituberculosis treatment
      2. 6 mo after treatment initiation for those treated with antituberculosis treatment (or at end of antituberculosis treatment).
    4. Appropriate antituberculosis treatment for presumed drug-susceptible tuberculosis should meet the following criteria:
      1. Treatment with standard regimens in accordance with local or international tuberculosis treatment guidelines
      2. Satisfactory adherence proposed as 80% adherence by pill count or self-reported
    5. Response to antituberculosis treatment should be evaluated at 2 mo after antituberculosis treatment has commenced using standardized forms with tick-box options for recording (eg, improvement or not of each clinical feature suggestive of tuberculosis disease indicated as Yes/No option), Complete resolution of presenting signs and symptoms
    6. Response to antituberculosis treatment is defined as
      1. Response to antituberculosis therapy: clinical features suggestive of tuberculosis disease that were present at baseline have improved, and there is no new clinical feature suggestive of tuberculosis; OR
      2. No response to antituberculosis therapy: clinical features suggestive of tuberculosis disease that were present at baseline have not improved or have worsened.

Abbreviations: 2TU, 2 tuberculin units; 5TU, 5 tuberculin units; CXR, chest radiograph; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; IGRA, interferon-γ release assay; NAAT, nucleic acid amplification test; PPD, purified protein derivative; WHO, World Health Organization.

a Previous symptoms are all relevant.

b If other causes are excluded or not responding to appropriate treatment thereof.