Table 3.
Study reference | Cas9 system |
Library size, genes targeted | Cell type(s) | Selection | Key findings with implications for screening |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wang et al., 2014 | WT Cas9 stably expressed. | 73,151 sgRNAs 7,114 genes 10 sgRNA/gene |
Human KBM7 (CML) HL60 (PML) |
6-thioguanine Etoposide Proliferation |
CRISPR-based KO screening is effective in both haploid and diploid cells. Off-target effects are minimal. |
Shalem et al., 2014 | WT Cas9 encoded in same lentivirus as sgRNA | 64,751 sgRNAs 18,080 genes 3-4 sgRNA/gene |
Human A375 (melanoma) HUES62 (stem cell line) |
Proliferation Vemurafenib |
CRISPR-based KO screening produces strong phenotypes that may be undetectable using RNAi. Hits have a high validation rate. |
Koike-Yusa et al., 2014 | WT Cas9 stably expressed | 87,897 sgRNAs 19,150 genes 2-5 sgRNA/gene |
Mouse JM8 (ES cell line) | Alpha toxin 6-thioguanine |
CRISPR is powerful enough to be used for recessive screens. Off target effects are low, subject to effective sgRNA design. Lentiviral-delivered sgRNA guide sequences are most effective if the first nucleotide is a G. |
Zhou et al., 2014 | WT Cas9 stably expressed, OCT4 stably expressed to boost U6 promoter | 869 sgRNA 291 genes ~3 sgRNA/gene |
Human HeLa (adenocarcinoma) | Diptheria toxin Chimaeric anthrax |
CRISPR has advantages over RNAi for knowledge-based screening with small focused libraries. It is important to select a clonal Cas9 cell line with a high modification efficiency. |
Bassett et al., 2015 | WT Cas9 encoded in same plasmid as sgRNA | 40,279 sgRNA 13,501 genes ~3 sgRNA/gene |
Drosophila S2R+ cells | Proliferation | First Drosophila whole genome sgRNA library. Plasmid transfection can be used in pooled approaches if DNA is diluted and cells are selected. |
Gilbert et al., 2014 | CRISPRi: dCas9-KRAB stably expressed CRISPRa: sunCas9 stably expressed |
206,421 sgRNAs 15,977 genes ~10 sgRNA/gene 198,810 sgRNAs 15,977 genes ~10 sgRNA/gene |
Human K562 (CML) | Proliferation Chimaeric cholera toxin-diptheria toxin catalytic A subunit |
Genome-wide activation and repression-based screens are robust and give complementary results. Off-target effects are extremely low due to mismatch intolerance. Perturbation of non-coding elements is achievable. |
Konermann et al., 2015 | SAM (synergistic activation mediator) with protein components stably expressed | 70,290 sgRNAs 23,430 genes 3 sgRNA/gene |
Human A375 (melanoma) | Vemurafenib | The crystal structure of Cas9 can inform effective engineering strategies for gene activation. Activation-based screening is an alternative to cDNA overexpression, and hits have a high validation rate. |
CML, chronic myeloid leukemia; CRISPRa, CRISPR activation; CRISPRi, CRISPR interference; PML, promyelocytic leukemia.