Ref (type) | Population | Outcome, Interventions | Results and statistical analysis | Effect size | Favours |
Fatigue severity | |||||
RCT 3-armed trial |
278 adults with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Improvement in fatigue severity (Checklist Individual Strength [CIS-fatigue])
8 months
27/83 (33%) with CBT 10/80 (13%) with guided support |
RR 2.6 for CBT v guided support 95% CI 1.3 to 5.0 RCT had high withdrawal rate; see Further information on studies for full details |
Moderate effect size | CBT |
RCT 3-armed trial |
278 adults with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Improvement in fatigue severity (self-reported)
8 months
42/74 (57%) with CBT 12/71 (17%) with guided support |
RR 3.4 for CBT v guided support 95% 1.9 to 5.8 RCT had high withdrawal rate; see Further information on studies for full details |
Moderate effect size | CBT |
RCT 3-armed trial |
278 adults with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Improvement in fatigue severity (CIS-fatigue)
8 months
27/83 (33%) with CBT 8/62 (13%) with no intervention |
RR 2.5 for CBT v no intervention 95% CI 1.2 to 5.2 RCT had high withdrawal rate; see Further information on studies for full details |
Moderate effect size | CBT |
RCT 3-armed trial |
278 adults with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Improvement in fatigue severity (self-reported)
8 months
42/74 (57%) with CBT 23/78 (30%) with no intervention |
RR 1.9 for CBT v no intervention 95% CI 1.3 to 2.9 RCT had high withdrawal rate; see Further information on studies for full details |
Small effect size | CBT |
RCT 3-armed trial |
153 adults with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Change in fatigue severity (Chalder Fatigue Score)
with group CBT with usual care Absolute results not reported |
Difference –2.61 for group CBT v usual care 95% CI –4.92 to –0.30 P = 0.03 |
Effect size not calculated | CBT |
RCT 3-armed trial |
153 adults with CFS, CDC criteria In review |
Change in fatigue severity (Chalder Fatigue Score)
with group CBT with education and support Absolute results not reported |
Difference –3.16 for group CBT v education and support 95% CI –5.59 to –0.74 P = 0.011 |
Effect size not calculated | CBT |
RCT 4-armed trial |
90 adults with a mean age of 39.6 years who fulfilled diagnostic criteria for CFS (not further defined) In review |
Mean fatigue score (profile of mood states subscale)
7 months (3 months after completion of treatment)
16.8 with CBT plus placebo 17.3 with usual care plus placebo |
Significance not assessed |
||
RCT 4-armed trial |
114 adults with CFS (as defined by CDC criteria); baseline fatigue severity scale (FSS) scores 6.05 in people having CBT, 5.82 in people having relaxation therapy In review |
Mean score on FSS
12 months
5.37 with CBT 5.62 with relaxation therapy |
Significance not assessed |
||
RCT |
69 children and adolescents aged 10 to 17 years with CFS (CDC criteria) |
Change in fatigue severity score (Checklist Individual Strength [CIS-fatigue])
5 months
–22.3 with CBT –7.6 with no intervention |
Absolute difference 14.5 95% CI 7.4 to 21.6 |
Effect size not calculated | CBT |
RCT |
63 adolescents aged 11–18 years with CFS (CDC or Oxford criteria) In review |
Mean fatigue score (Chalder Fatigue Scale)
6 months post treatment
13.3 with family-focused CBT 14.2 with psycho-education |
Treatment effect +0.24 95% CI –3.61 to +4.10 P = 0.9 |
Not significant | |
RCT |
131 adolescents aged 12–18 years with CFS (CDC criteria) In review |
Fatigue severity (CIS-20)
6 months
24.0 with internet CBT 42.3 with usual care |
Mean difference –18.3 95% CI –22.9 to –13.7 P <0.0001 |
Effect size not calculated | CBT |
RCT 4-armed trial |
641 adults with CFS (Oxford criteria) |
Chalder Fatigue Questionnaire
24 weeks
21.5 with CBT 24.0 with specialist medical care |
Significance not assessed |
||
RCT 4-armed trial |
641 adults with CFS (Oxford criteria) |
Chalder Fatigue Questionnaire
52 weeks
20.3 with CBT 23.8 with specialist medical care |
Mean difference –3.4 95% CI –5.0 to –1.8 P = 0.0001 |
Effect size not calculated | CBT |