Table 1. Characteristics of the animal studies included in the meta-analysis.
First author (year) | Language | n | Mode of intervention | Period of PC(day) | Source of indicators | Outcome indicators |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Su-Jin2009 [14] | English | 10 | Feed | <30d | Tissue | 2.3.6 |
Mi-Ok Shin2010 [15] | English | 6 | Feed | <30d | Tissue | 1 |
Xiayuan2010 [16] | Chinese | 8 | Gavage | <30d | Serum | 1.2 |
Adem Guler2011 [17] | English | 8 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2.3.4 |
HUANG Qi-liang2011 [18] | English | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 1.2 |
Lijianling2011 [19] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2 |
Osama M.Ashour2011 [20] | English | 12 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2.5.6 |
Xielimei2011 [21] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2 |
Soo-Kyong Choi2012 [22] | English | 8 | Feed | <30d | Tissue | 2.3.5 |
Vijayakumar2012 [23] | English | 6 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 2.3.5.6 |
Wangweifen2012 [24] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2 |
Xiao GENG2012 [25] | English | 8 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2 |
Yu Deng2012 [26] | English | 8 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2.3.5 |
zhangxuan2012 [27] | English | 16 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2.3.6 |
zhaopeng2012 [28] | Chinese | 12 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 1.2.3 |
Bailijun2013 [29] | Chinese | 5 | Gavage | <30d | Serum | 1.2.3.6 |
Dingyusong2013 [30] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2 |
Hanaa A2013 [31] | English | 6 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2.3.4 |
Jiangyanfei2013 [32] | Chinese | 12 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 1.2 |
Miaozhiru2013 [33] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 1.2.3.5 |
E Bakar2014 [34] | English | 7 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 1.2.4.5 |
Gaolu2014 [35] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 1.2.3.6 |
Hua Zhang2014 [36] | English | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2.5.6 |
Juan Xiao2014 [37] | English | 10 | Gavage | <30d | Serum | 1.2.3 |
Noorah2014 [38] | English | 10 | Gavage | <30d | Tissue | 2.6 |
Tingting Ren2014 [39] | English | 8 | Gavage | ≥30d | Serum | 2.5 |
Wangcheng2014 [40] | Chinese | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2.4.5 |
Ying GAO2014 [41] | English | 10 | Gavage | ≥30d | Tissue | 1.2.3 |
Esrafil Mansouri2015 [42] | English | 10 | Gavage | <30d | Serum | 1.2.3.6 |
Note: n = number of experimental animals; 1 = malondialdehyde, 2 = superoxide dismutase, 3 = glutathione peroxidase, 4 = total antioxidative capacity, 5 = glutathione, and 6 = catalase.