Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Oct 1.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Trials. 2015 Sep 15;12(5):467–475. doi: 10.1177/1740774515597686

Table 1.

Examples of potential harms/burdens and benefits/advantages of PCTs by type and target of intervention

Target of
Intervention
or Interaction
Potential Harms/Burdens Potential Benefits/Advantages
Medical and Behavioral Interventions (drug, device, or procedure; educational, attitudinal, or adherence)
Patient
  • Inconvenience of regimen

  • Loss of privacy

  • Poorer health outcomes

  • Psychosocial discomfort

  • Commitment to regimen

  • More time with care teams

  • Better health outcomes

  • Fulfillment of altruistic desires

Clinician
  • Increased time commitment

  • Additional professional oversight

  • Decreased confidence/reputation

  • Decreased clinical autonomy

  • Increased medical error

  • Advancing the field

  • Improved care delivery

  • Increased confidence/reputation

  • Increased patient trust

  • Decreased medical error

System
  • Increased financial costs

  • Decreased staff/patient satisfaction

  • Decreased workflow efficiency

  • Decreased ranking/reputation

  • New liabilities

  • Decreased financial costs

  • Improved staff/patient satisfaction

  • Increased workflow efficiency

  • Improved ranking/reputation

  • Better management of liabilities

Information Technology Interventions (electronic data management, measurement, or communication)
Patient
  • Increased potential for loss of privacy

  • Decontextualization of disease

  • Depersonalization of care and communication

  • Lower accessibility (limited resources or tech capabilities)

  • Better adherence to regimen

  • Better health outcomes

  • Improved continuity of care

  • Greater access to clinicians

  • More thorough understanding of disease condition

  • Better opportunity to report patient-level outcomes

Clinician
  • Greater security-associated liabilities

  • Increased frustration and inconvenience

  • Depersonalization of care

  • Increased dependence

  • Insufficient communication or understanding

  • Increased medical error

  • Increased efficiency and optimization of care delivery

  • Improved communication accuracy

  • Improved communication speed

  • Broadened medical skill set

  • Decreased medical error

System
  • Perceived endorsement of experimental technology

  • Unforeseen stresses to system resources

  • Incompatibility with existing information technologies

  • Better staffing synergies

  • Fewer care redundancies

  • Faster rollout/uptake of system-wide improvements

  • Better data interoperability

  • Increased monitoring capabilities