Skip to main content
. 2015 Oct 9;9:349. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2015.00349

Table 1.

Clinical trials of tDCS and behavioral addictions: general and clinical characteristics.

Studies Studied condition N Participants inclusion criteria Mean age (years) Proportion of females Main exclusion criteria Design Objective Main experimental conditions Main outcome measures Main results Drop out (reason)
Fregni et al., 2008b Food craving 23 Healthy subjects aged 18–55.
Frequent food craving (>3 times/day) and strong urges to eat
23.7 91.3% NS Randomized Sham-controlled
Double-blind Crossover design
Investigate the effect of tDCS on food cue-induced craving-related behavior Exposition to food and watching a movie of food associated with strong craving Food craving (VAS) and food consumption before and after treatment
Visual attention to food using an eye tracking system
Craving for viewed foods was reduced by anode right/cathode left tDCS
After sham stimulation, exposure to real food or food-related movie increased craving
After anode left/cathode right tDCS, the food-related stimuli did not increase craving levels
2 (School work)
Goldman et al., 2011 Food craving 19 Healthy subjects aged 21–70 with frequent food cravings (≥3 times/week during the past month)
BMI < 40
32.4 68.4% Pregnancy
History of an ED or depression Suicidality
Implanted metal devices
History of seizures, brain surgery
Randomized
Sham-controlled
Single-blind Within-subject crossover design
Investigate the effect of tDCS on food cue-induced craving and the ability to resist foods Twenty-four images of foods (e.g., ice cream, cheese-burgers, pizza) were presented in random Food craving and ability to resist tasting (VAS) while viewing food image Food cravings ratings were reduced in both conditions
The percent change in self-reported cravings from pre- to post-stimulation was significantly greater for real stimulation
Decrease in food craving, particularly for sweets and carbohydrates
No change in food consumption
1 (NS)
Montenegro et al., 2012 Hunger, satiety and desire to eat sensations 9 Overweight subjects 2–3 h fasting 24 44.4% Cardiovascular disease
Pregnancy, History of eating disorders
Depression
Implanted metal parts
Randomized
Single-blinded
Sham-Controlled
Crossover design
Investigate the effect of tDCS isolated or combined with aerobic exercise on the desire to eat, hunger, and satiety No exposition to food Appetite sensations (VAS) evaluated at four moments: baseline; after tDCS; post-exercise; 30 min post-exercise tDCS on left DLPFC decreased the desire to eat at baseline
tDCS associated with exercise had greater suppressing effect in desire to eat compared to either
tDCS or exercise alone tDCS associated with exercise decreased hunger and increased satiety immediately after exercise
0
Kekic et al., 2014 Food craving and temporal discounting 17 Healthy women aged 18–60 with frequent food cravings (≥1 per day) 26.4 100% SUD
Major psychiatric disorder Current or past history of an eating disorder
Personal or family history of seizures Implanted metal devices
Pregnancy
Randomized
Double-blind
Sham-controlled Within-subjects crossover design
Investigate the effect of tDCS on food cravings, intertemporal choice behavior, actual food consumption and temporal discounting Exposition to real food VAS measuring baseline hunger
FCT
FCQ-S
Saliva sample TD task
tDCS reduced cravings for sweet but not savory foods Participants who exhibited more reflective choice behavior were more susceptible to the anticraving effects of tDCS than those who displayed more impulsive choice behavior. 1 (Skin irritation)
Khedr et al., 2014 Urge to restrict food intake 7 Treatment-resistant AN
BMI between 14 and 17.5 kg/m2
21.75 85.7% Drugs (dopaminergic, psychotropic, antiepileptic, or hormonal drugs Estrogen) at least 2 weeks before the study Six patients had been receiving antidepressant (SSRls) which was kept constant throughout the study Open-label, single-arm study Evaluate the acceptability of tDCS as a potential treatment for AN
Investigate the effect of tDCS on the urge to restrict food intake and symptoms of depression associated with AN.
No exposition to food EAT
EDI
BDI
Significant effect of time (pre, post, and 1 month later) on the three rating scores
Significant correlation between the percent improvement of BDI and EAT and between BDI and EDI
Ten daily sessions of anodal tDCS over the left DLPFC improved symptoms of both depression and AN for up to 1 month
0
Lapenta et al., 2014 Food consumption and ERP-indexed inhibitory control 9 Healthy females.
Frequent (>3 times/day) and strong urges to eat
23.4 ± 2 years) 100% Neuropsychiatric disorder
History of abuse of alcohol or another drug
Psychiatric medication
Pregnancy
Eating disorder
Randomized
Double-blind Sham-controlled
Crossover design
Evaluate the cognitive ERPs that are associated with the effects of DLPFC tDCS on food craving Exposition to food and watching a movie of food associated with strong craving Go/No-go task that contained pictures of food and furniture (a control visual stimulus). ERP during a Go/No-Go task Food craving (VAS) while exposed to real food and a movie of food Snack intake;
Attentional bias for food (eye tracking)
Active DLPFC tDCS (anode right/cathode left), compared with sham stimulation, reduced the frontal N2 component and enhanced the P3a component of responses to No-go stimuli, regardless of the stimulus condition (food or furniture). Active tDCS was also associated with a reduction in caloric intake 0
Jauch-Chara et al., 2014 Food intake 14 Healthy young normal-weight men with BMI from 20 to 25. Low cognitive restraint, low disinhibition, and normal susceptibility to hunger scores 24.8 0% Any medication
Acute and chronic medical diseases
Alcohol or drug abuse, Smoking
Participation in competitive sports
Disturbances in sleep continuity
Randomized
Sham-controlled
Single-blind
Code-based,
Counter-balanced
Crossover design
Investigate the effect of repetitive tDCS to the right
DLPFC on food intake
Exposition to food and consomption Subjective appetite (ratings and VAS)
Food intake behavior from a standardized ad libitum buffet
tDCS reduced food consumption in humans 0

AN, Anorexia Nervosia; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; BMI (in kg/m2), Body Mass Index; DLPFC, Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex; EAT, Eating Attitude Test; EDI, Eating Disorder Inventory; ERPs, event-related potentials; FCQ-S, Food Craving Questionnaire-State; FCT, Food Challenge Task; NS, Not Specified; SUD, Substance Use Disorders; TD task, temporal discounting task; SSRls, serotonin reuptake inhibitors; tDCS, transcranial direct current stimulation; VAS, Visual Analog Scales.