Table 1.
Experimental set-up | Lameness reference | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Source | Sensor type | Number of cows | Normal routine | N° of variables per variable type | Automated measurements | In real- time | Person performing scoring | Number classes used | Cut-off levels for lameness |
Rajkondawar et al. [8] | 2 floor plates with 4 load cells | 23 | no | weight variables (6) | no | no | herdsman and veterinarian | 1 to 5 | |
Rajkondawar et al. [9] | 2 floor plates with 4 load cells | 31 | no | weight variables (5) | yes | yes | observer | 1 to 5 | classes 1 - 2 - 3 |
Pastell and Kujala [19] | 4 balance system on floor in milking robot | 73 | yes | weight variables (26) | yes | yes | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 and 2 + no claw lesions lame: 3 and more |
Chapinal et al. [23] | speed | 66 | no | speed | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 - 2 lame: 3 - 4- 5 |
weighing platform with 4 balances | weight variables (12) | no | |||||||
Pedometer | lying behaviour (2) | yes | |||||||
Chapinal et al. [24] | speed | 57 | no | speed | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 - 2 lame: 3 - 4- 5 |
weighing platform with 4 balances | weight variables (12) | no | |||||||
Pedometer | lying behaviour (2) | yes | |||||||
Pastell et al. [25] | weighing platform with 4 balances | 55 | no | weight variables (16) | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 - 2 lame: 3 - 4- 5 |
Liu et al. [12] | StepMetrix | 346 | no | weight variables (5) and symmetry variables | yes | yes | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 -2 (3) lame: (3) - 4 - 5 |
Chapinal and Tucker [26] | weighing platform with 4 balances | 57 | no | steps (validate by camera observations + frequency of steps + weight shifting | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 - 2 - 3 lame: 4 - 5 |
Thorup et al. [16] | 2 force plates with 4 load cells | 9 | no | Full curve symmetry in 3 dimensions | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | Non-lame: 1 lame: 2 - 5 |
Normal Routine: cows walk in normal routine or were guided in an experimental set up: Automated: measurements were automated without presence of an operator; real-time: results of variables are available in real-time.