Table 3.
Experimental set-up | Lameness reference | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Source | Sensor type | Number of cows | Normal routine | N° of variables per variable type | Automated measurements | In real- time | Person performing scoring | Number classes used | Cut-off levels for lameness |
Song et al. [34] | digital camera | 15 | no | 1 (trackway overlap) | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | all classes separate |
Pluk et al. [35] | digital camera | 15/66 | no/yes | 1 (trackway overlap) | no/yes | no/no | observer | 1 to 5 | all classes separate |
Pluk et al. [36] | digital camera combined with Gaitwise-system | 70/75 | yes/yes | 3 (touch angle, release angle, range of motion in the fetlock joint) | no/yes | no/no | observer | 1 to 3 | all classes separate |
Poursaberi et al. [37] | digital camera | 28/66 | yes/yes | 1 (back posture) | no/no | no/no | observer | 1 to 3 | all classes separate |
Blackie et al. [64] | leg markers, digital camera | 56 | no | 7 (stride length front and hind, tracking distance, hock flexion, max fetlock height, height of spine, head position) | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | all classes separate (no 4 and 5 used) |
Viazzi et al. [39] | digital camera | 98 | yes | 1 (body movement pattern) | no | no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 + 2 lame: 3 severely lame: 4 + 5 |
Van Hertem et al. [43] | 3D-digital camera | 186 | yes | 1 (back posture measurement) | yes | no | observer | 1 to 5 | - all classes separate; - all classes separate with 1 level tolerance; - non-lame: 1 + 2 lame: 3 – 5 |
Viazzi et al. [40] | digital camera and 3D-digital camera | 273 | yes | 1 back posture in 2D 1 back posture in 3D | no/yes | no/no | observer | 1 to 5 | non-lame: 1 + 2 lame: 3 - 5 |
Normal Routine: cows walk in normal routine or were guided in an experimental set up: Automated: measurements were automated without presence of an operator; real-time: results of variables are available in real-time.