Table 2.
Data on Cognitive Decline in Atrial Fibrillation
Author | Year | Patients | AF Patients | Population | Follow-up | Cognitive Function Assessment | AF Association Cognitive Decline |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Farina62 | 1997 | 74 | 37 | 21 PAF, 16 persistent AF | Cross-section | MMSE* | Statistically significant for persistent, not significant for paroxysmal |
Ott63 | 1997 | 6584 | 195 | Mean age 69±9 years | Cross-section | MMSE and Geriatric Mental State Schedule | Adjusted OR 1.7 (1. 2 to 2.5) |
Kilander64 | 1998 | 952 | 44 | Mean age 72±1 years | Cross-section | Trail Making Tests A and B, MMSE | Unadjusted, statistically significant |
O’Connell65 | 1998 | 81 | 27 | Mean age 72±1 years | Cross-section | Mini-Mental Status† | MMSE not statistically significant |
Rozzini66 | 1999 | 269 | 55 | 13 PAF, 42 persistent AF | Cross-section | MMSE | Adjusted OR for paroxysmal AF 1.2 (0.3 to 4.8), OR for persistent AF 3.2 (1.5 to 6.6) |
Elias67 | 2006 | 1011 | 59 | Men, mean age 61 years | Cross-section | Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale‡ | Adjusted, statistically significant |
Jozwiak68 | 2006 | 2314 | 547 | Median age 80 years (75 to 86) | Cross-section | MMSE | OR 1.56 (1.27 to 1.92, P =0.0001) |
Debette69 | 2007 | 83 | 32 | Mean age 62 years | Cross-section | MMSE | Adjusted OR 8.1 (1.9 to 34.6, P =0.008) |
Rastas70 | 2007 | 553 | 122 | 85 years and older | Cross-section | MMSE§ | Unadjusted, not statistically significant |
Knecht60 | 2008 | 533 | 87 | Mean age 63±8 years | Cross-section | Composite|| | Adjusted, statistically significant |
Bilato71 | 2009 | 1576 | 135 | Mean age 74 years | Cross-section | MMSE | Adjusted OR 1.14 (0.73 to 1.80) |
Bellomo72 | 2012 | 57 | 26 | Mean age 72±8 years | Cross-section | MMSE | Adjusted, statistically significant |
Gaita73 | 2013 | 270 | 180 | 61% with CHA2-DS2-VaSc <2 | Cross-section | Repeatable Battery for the Assessment of Neuropsychological Status | Unadjusted, statistically significant |
Stefansdottir41 | 2013 | 4251 | 330 | Mean age 76±5 years | Cross-section | Modified California Verbal Learning Test | Adjusted, statistically significant |
Horstmann74 | 2014 | 788 | 165 | Mean age 67±14 years | Cross-section | Informant questionnaire on cognitive decline in the elderly | OR of 2.97 (1.0 to 8.8, P =0.05) |
Tilvis75 | 2004 | 650 | Mean 5 years | MMSE and Clinical Dementia Rating | RR 2.8 | ||
Forti76 | 2006 | 431 | 13 | Mean age 75±5 years | Mean of 4 years | MMSE | Adjusted HR 1.10 (0.40 to 3.03) |
Park44 | 2007 | 362 | 174 | Mean age 76 years | Mean 3 years | MMSE | No significant association |
Peters77 | 2009 | 3336 | 190 | Mean age 53±6 years | Mean of 2 years | MMSE | HR 1.031 (0.619 to 1.718) |
Bunch78 | 2010 | 37 025 | 10 161 | Mean age 61±18 years | Mean of 5 years | ICD-9 code for dementia | Adjusted OR 1.73 (P =0.001) |
Dublin79 | 2011 | 3045 | 402 | Median age 74 years | Mean of 7 years | Cognitive Abilities Screening Instrument | Adjusted HR 1.50 (1.16 to 1.94) |
Li80 | 2011 | 650 | 30 | Mean age 67 years | Mean of 5 years | MMSE | Adjusted OR 1.09 (0.54 to 2.20, P =0.82) |
Marengoni81 | 2011 | 785 | 68 | Mean age 78 years | Mean of 4 years | MMSE | Adjusted HR 0.8 (0.4 to 1.5) |
Marzona22 | 2012 | 31 546 | 3068 | Mean age 67±7 years | Median 56 months | MMSE | HR 1.30 (1.14 to 1.49) |
Haring82 | 2013 | 6455 | 255 | Women age 60 to 84 years | Mean of 8 years | Annual modified MMSE | HR 1.25 (0.78 to 2.0) |
Thacker83 | 2013 | 5150 | 552 | Mean age 73±5 years | Mean of 7 years | Annual modified MMSE | Adjusted, statistically significant |
Chen43 | 2014 | 935 | 48 | Mean age 62±4 years | Median 10.6 years | Delayed word recall, digit symbol substitution, first-letter word fluency | Statistically significant |
AF indicates atrial fibrillation; HR, hazard ratio; ICD-9, International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision; MMSE, Mini Mental Status Exam; OR, odds ratio; PAF, paroxysmal atrial fibrillation; RR, relative risk. Data are displayed as median (interquartile range), mean +/− standard devision, OR (95% confidence interval), and HR (95% confidence interval).
Also includes Weschsler Adult Intelligence, Logical Memory Test, Paired Associated Learning Test, Corsi’s Block Tapping Test, Attentional Matrices, Raven Progressive Matrices, Judgment of Line Orientation, Rey-Osterrieth Complex, Verbal Fluency for Letters, Wisconsin Sorting Card Test.
Also includes National Adult Reading Test, Wechsler Logical Memory Test, Rey Complex Figure Test, Digit Span, Paced Auditory Serial Addition Test.
Also includes Wechsler Memory Scale, Hooper Visual Organization Test, Halstead-Reitan Battery.
Also includes Short Portable Mental Status Questionnaire, Clinical Dementia Rating.
Auditory verbal learning test, Stroop test, Trail-making test, Wechsler Memory Scale, category and letter fluency, Rey-Osterrieth complex figure test, digit symbol substitution test.