Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Oct 15.
Published in final edited form as: J Biomech. 2015 Aug 28;48(13):3634–3642. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2015.08.011

Table 1.

Mean ± standard deviation (SD) within each sub-tissue zone for all measurements from medial tibia cartilage specimens at each OA-time-point with and without loading

Sub-tissue Zone 8wk-Contralateral
8wk-OA
12wk-Contralateral
12wk-OA
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
T2(0°)-Unloaded [ms]
Bulk 26.0 7.1 26.4 6.0 31.1 9.1 29.7 6.6
SZ 53.6 15.1 59.1 12.9 58.3 20.7 66.2 17.4
TZ 54.9 13.1 56.7 11.4 64.5 18.8 63.9 17.6
RZ1 23.3 8.1 24.4 7.2 30.5 9.5 27.7 6.5
RZ2 9.9 2.8 9.6 2.0 13.4 4.1 11.6 2.2
T2(0°)-Loaded [ms]
Bulk 25.7 c 7.4 26.1 c 6.2 24.2 c 3.8 25.5 b 4.1
SZ 36.6 a 10.8 37.7 a 9.7 30.5 b 4.9 31.8 a 5.7
TZ 45.3 a 11.9 46.4 a 11.1 43.1 b 5.3 48.1 b 12.1
RZ1 22.3 c 10.1 22.1 b 7.2 21.8 b 4.3 23.6 b 4.6
RZ2 9.6 c 3.9 8.9 c 2.6 11.2 b 2.2 11.5 c 3.5
T2(55°)-Unloaded [ms]
Bulk 45.4 10.4 49.2 8.8 46.7 12.3 48.2 10.8
SZ 56.6 13.7 58.9 11.3 49.3 18.1 63.2 12.3
TZ 58.6 13.7 62.8 11.5 55.4 20.6 64.9 11.7
RZ1 50.0 13.1 54.6 12.6 53.3 20.4 56.0 16.5
RZ2 32.6 9.7 34.7 8.6 36.5 12.4 35.6 8.0
T2(55°)-Loaded [ms]
Bulk 36.7 10.3 37.5 a 9.3 39.0 a 9.7 40.0 a 7.8
SZ 37.5 a 12.0 35.5 a 9.9 30.8 b 5.2 37.0 b 9.3
TZ 44.7 a 11.9 45.4 a 11.9 46.3 c 9.3 50.6 b 13.5
RZ1 39.8 a 13.9 41.1 a 11.9 49.0 c 15.5 45.6 b 15.0
RZ2 26.8 b 9.2 28.0 a 8.4 35.6 c 11.1 31.7 c 11.3
Real Thickness-Unloaded [μm]
Bulk 1062.8 301.9 1133.4 367.0 1148.7 337.9 1152.5 321.0
SZ 40.5 13.2 43.7 22.9 33.7 14.0 28.4 11.4
TZ 150.8 34.5 152.0 44.2 161.3 45.5 157.0 42.8
RZ1 438.2 145.2 468.8 172.2 456.1 121.8 449.5 116.9
RZ2 428.9 144.0 468.4 172.4 447.3 123.2 437.3 117.4
Real Thickness-Loaded [μm]
Bulk 826.2 a 322.0 816.0 a 250.0 839.7 a 184.0 867.4 a 221.3
SZ 44.0 c 20.0 44.8 c 22.5 42.5 b 14.0 50.1 a 14.1
TZ 166.0 c 52.7 183.5 c 84.4 170.1 c 40.6 155.6 c 39.2
RZ1 316.8 a 145.9 299.2 a 105.1 319.7 a 82.2 326.3 a 106.8
RZ2 305.7 a 143.3 288.5 a 107.3 312.4 a 78.8 320.9 a 106.1
Relative Thickness-Unloaded [%]
SZ 4.0 1.4 4.2 3.0 3.3 1.8 3.8 3.8
TZ 14.9 3.8 14.5 5.8 15.5 6.3 15.1 4.3
RZ1 41.0 2.1 40.7 3.9 40.9 3.7 41.6 2.3
RZ2 40.1 2.2 40.6 4.0 40.2 4.0 40.5 2.3
Relative Thickness-Loaded [%]
SZ 5.9 b 3.0 6.7 b 5.7 5.2 b 2.1 6.3 c 2.6
TZ 21.0 a 5.7 22.9 a 6.3 20.9 b 6.7 19.4 b 6.5
RZ1 37.5 a 3.8 36.2 a 4.9 37.4 b 4.0 37.5 b 4.4
RZ2 35.9 a 3.4 34.7 a 5.2 36.5 b 3.7 36.8 b 4.3
Strain [%]
Bulk 23.2 13.8 26.4 13.5 25.8 13.7 27.0 10.5
Zone 23.2 13.8 26.4 13.5 19.6 9.5 24.6 13.8

The statistical results of the paired student t-test between unloaded and loaded on parameters were shown by the superscript letter:

a

P<0.001,

b

p<0.05,

c

p>0.05