Table 3. Mean apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) values (× 10−3 mm2s-1) of 3.0-Tesla using MRI from normal parenchyma, benign lesions, and malignant lesions, and ADC values’ utility in tumor characterization.
Bogner et al (2009) | Cakir et al (2013) | Park et al (2015) | Dong et al (2014) | Nogueira et al (2014) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Field strength and manufacturer | 3T (Siemens) | 3T (Philips) | 3T (Siemens) | 3T (GE) | 3T (Siemens) |
N | 51 | 52 | 110 | 87 | 53 |
B values (mm2s-1) | 500, 850 | 0, 50, 850, 1000, 1500; lower b range 0–1000 and higher b range 0–1500 | 0, 100 | 0, 800 | 50, 200, 400, 600, 800, 1000, 2000, 3000 |
MRI sequence order | DWI prior to DCE | DWI prior to DCE | UN | UN | DWI prior to DCE |
ROI type and placement | Three-dimensional large ROI, avoiding fatty and necrotic tissue | Average of automatic double reading; having two combined b values; excluding hemorrhagic, cystic, and necrotic areas | Average of manual reading repeated 2–5 times; having two combined values; excluding hemorrhagic, cystic, and necrotic areas | Mean value of 3 round ROIs avoiding necrosis and hemorrhage, size 10 to 20 mm2 | ROI placed on the area of highest hyperintensity on DCE, size 10 mm2 |
ADC breast parenchyma | 1.87±0.22 | Lower: 1.66±0.34, higher: 1.48±0.30 | 1.51±0.29 | 1.696 | 1.99±0.27 |
ADC benign lesion | 1.51±0.22 | Lower: 1.27±0.37, higher: 1.20±0.40 | 1.41±0.56 | NS | 1.71±0.35 |
ADC malignant tumor | 0.99±0.18 | Lower: 0.82±0.07 and b range 0–1500: 0.82±0.08 | 0.88±0.15 | 1.065 | 1.08±0.25 |
ADC cut-off for malignancy | 1.25 | b range 0–1000: 1.23, higher 1.12 | NS | NS | 1.41 |
Sensitivity (%) | 96 | Lower: 92.9, higher: 96.2 | NS | NS | 94.3 |
Specificity (%) | 94 | Lower: 54.5, higher: 59.1 | NS | NS | 87.5 |
Positive Predictive Value (%) | NS | Lower: 72.2, higher73.5 | NS | NS | 91.7 |
Negative Predictive Value (%) | NS | Lower: 85.7, higher: 92.9 | NS | NS | 91.3 |
Accuracy (%) | 95 | NS | NS | NS | 91.5 |
T = tesla
ROI = region of interest
N = number of patients
NS = not studied
DWI = diffusion-weighted imaging sequence
DCE = dynamic contrast-enhanced imaging sequence
UN = unspecified.