Table 4.
Expression stability ranking of the 11 candidate reference genes.
Method | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(A) RANKING ORDER UNDER BIOTIC STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE) | |||||||||||
NormFinder | RAN | ACT7 | EF1α | DnaJ | UBQ | UBI | 18S rRNA | TUBβ | UBC | TUBα | ACT |
geNorm | ACT7/RAN | DnaJ | UBQ | EF1α | UBI | 18S rRNA | UBC | TUBβ | TUBα | ACT | |
BestKeeper | 18S rRNA | UBI | ACT7 | DnaJ | RAN | UBQ | EF1α | ACT | UBC | TUBα | TUBβ |
Comprehensive ranking | RAN | ACT7 | DnaJ | 18S rRNA | UBI | EF1α | UBQ | UBC | TUBβ | ACT | TUBα |
(B) RANKING ORDER UNDER DIFFERENT TISSUES (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE) | |||||||||||
NormFinder | TUBβ | EF1α | RAN | UBI | ACT7 | DnaJ | UBQ | UBC | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT |
geNorm | TUBβ/UBI | EF1α | RAN | ACT7 | UBQ | DnaJ | UBC | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT | |
BestKeeper | UBI | TUBβ | DnaJ | RAN | UBQ | UBC | TUBα | EF1α | 18S rRNA | ACT7 | ACT |
Comprehensive ranking | TUBβ | UBI | EF1α | RAN | DnaJ | UBQ | ACT7 | UBC | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT |
(C) RANKING ORDER UNDER NACL STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE) | |||||||||||
NormFinder | ACT7 | RAN | UBQ | EF1α | TUBα | UBC | DnaJ | TUBβ | UBI | 18S rRNA | ACT |
geNorm | EF1α/RAN | ACT7 | DnaJ | UBC | UBI | UBQ | TUBα | TUBβ | 18S rRNA | ACT | |
BestKeeper | TUBα | UBC | UBI | RAN | UBQ | EF1α | TUBβ | DnaJ | ACT7 | 18S rRNA | ACT |
Comprehensive ranking | RAN | ACT7 | EF1α | TUBα | UBC | UBQ | UBI | DnaJ | TUBβ | 18S rRNA | ACT |
(D) RANKING ORDER UNDER PEG STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE) | |||||||||||
NormFinder | RAN | ACT7 | DnaJ | UBC | EF1α | UBI | TUBβ | UBQ | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT |
geNorm | EF1α/UBC | UBI | RAN | DnaJ | ACT7 | TUBβ | UBQ | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT | |
BestKeeper | TUBα | DnaJ | UBC | UBI | 18S rRNA | TUBβ | UBQ | ACT | RAN | ACT7 | EF1α |
Comprehensive ranking | UBC | DnaJ | RAN | UBI | EF1α | TUBα | ACT7 | TUBβ | UBQ | 18S rRNA | ACT |
(E) RANKING ORDER UNDER TOTAL SAMPLES (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE) | |||||||||||
NormFinder | RAN | ACT7 | EF1α | DnaJ | UBQ | UBI | TUBβ | UBC | TUBα | 18S rRNA | ACT |
geNorm | ACT7/RAN | DnaJ | UBQ | EF1α | UBI | UBC | TUBβ | 18S rRNA | TUBα | ACT | |
BestKeeper | UBI | 18S rRNA | DnaJ | ACT7 | EF1α | TUBβ | UBC | ACT | RAN | UBQ | TUBα |
Comprehensive ranking | ACT7 | RAN | DnaJ | UBI | EF1α | UBQ | 18S rRNA | TUBβ | UBC | ACT | TUBα |