Skip to main content
. 2015 Oct 14;6:848. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2015.00848

Table 4.

Expression stability ranking of the 11 candidate reference genes.

Method 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
(A) RANKING ORDER UNDER BIOTIC STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE)
NormFinder RAN ACT7 EF1α DnaJ UBQ UBI 18S rRNA TUBβ UBC TUBα ACT
geNorm ACT7/RAN DnaJ UBQ EF1α UBI 18S rRNA UBC TUBβ TUBα ACT
BestKeeper 18S rRNA UBI ACT7 DnaJ RAN UBQ EF1α ACT UBC TUBα TUBβ
Comprehensive ranking RAN ACT7 DnaJ 18S rRNA UBI EF1α UBQ UBC TUBβ ACT TUBα
(B) RANKING ORDER UNDER DIFFERENT TISSUES (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE)
NormFinder TUBβ EF1α RAN UBI ACT7 DnaJ UBQ UBC TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
geNorm TUBβ/UBI EF1α RAN ACT7 UBQ DnaJ UBC TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
BestKeeper UBI TUBβ DnaJ RAN UBQ UBC TUBα EF1α 18S rRNA ACT7 ACT
Comprehensive ranking TUBβ UBI EF1α RAN DnaJ UBQ ACT7 UBC TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
(C) RANKING ORDER UNDER NACL STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE)
NormFinder ACT7 RAN UBQ EF1α TUBα UBC DnaJ TUBβ UBI 18S rRNA ACT
geNorm EF1α/RAN ACT7 DnaJ UBC UBI UBQ TUBα TUBβ 18S rRNA ACT
BestKeeper TUBα UBC UBI RAN UBQ EF1α TUBβ DnaJ ACT7 18S rRNA ACT
Comprehensive ranking RAN ACT7 EF1α TUBα UBC UBQ UBI DnaJ TUBβ 18S rRNA ACT
(D) RANKING ORDER UNDER PEG STRESS (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE)
NormFinder RAN ACT7 DnaJ UBC EF1α UBI TUBβ UBQ TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
geNorm EF1α/UBC UBI RAN DnaJ ACT7 TUBβ UBQ TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
BestKeeper TUBα DnaJ UBC UBI 18S rRNA TUBβ UBQ ACT RAN ACT7 EF1α
Comprehensive ranking UBC DnaJ RAN UBI EF1α TUBα ACT7 TUBβ UBQ 18S rRNA ACT
(E) RANKING ORDER UNDER TOTAL SAMPLES (BETTER-GOOD-AVERAGE)
NormFinder RAN ACT7 EF1α DnaJ UBQ UBI TUBβ UBC TUBα 18S rRNA ACT
geNorm ACT7/RAN DnaJ UBQ EF1α UBI UBC TUBβ 18S rRNA TUBα ACT
BestKeeper UBI 18S rRNA DnaJ ACT7 EF1α TUBβ UBC ACT RAN UBQ TUBα
Comprehensive ranking ACT7 RAN DnaJ UBI EF1α UBQ 18S rRNA TUBβ UBC ACT TUBα