Table 1.
Theme | Lesson(s) learned | Challenges specific to exome and genome sequencing |
---|---|---|
Managing expectations in pretest and post-test counseling, negative findings do not mean the condition is not genetic | Elicit perceived goals and expectations both during informed consent and after return of results to identify and address misconceptions | Belief that all pathogenic genetic variation can be identified and the clinical significance will be clear |
Context matters: follow-up for recommendations from IFs in healthy and ill patient-participants | Both healthy and ill patient-participants who receive IFs may face challenges with adherence to screening/testing recommendations. Ill patient-participants may focus on the diagnostic results and over-interpret a negative result as ‘good news’ | Limited pretest discussion of the unanticipated condition(s) and implications of results. (Ill) Emphasizing importance of follow-up for medically actionable IFs in the context of more acute concerns. (Healthy) Lack of personal/family history may affect motivation and access to care |
Considerations for returning large amounts of data | Discussing multiple findings may require two or more visits, separate report sections for the discussion of each finding and an accompanying counseling letter | Returning and discussing several additional findings unrelated to the primary diagnosis |
Differing responses from families to the same result | Identify and explore unique thoughts and emotions of the patient-participant | Anticipating reactions when the range of possible results has not been discussed in detail prior to testing |
Challenges with follow-up testing for family members of sequenced patient- participants | Targeted clinical follow-up testing may not be available to or feasible for relatives/partners | Follow-up testing for genes covered by genome/exome testing may not be available outside of a research study |
Navigating the atypical presentation of well-known Mendelian condition | Challenging to identify resources, anticipate future medical implications and predict the manifestation of the condition in other family members | Providing genetic counseling for patients with atypical presentations will take more time and take place more often than with targeted gene sequencing |
Deceased patients and communicating results with family members | Establish a plan during informed consent regarding whom, if anyone, to return results to posthumously including what type of results to share | Deciding what results to share from broad range of possible findings increased likelihood due to use of exome and genome sequencing tests in later stage cancer patients |
IF: Incidental finding.