TABLE 1.
Author | Type of study | Setting | Duration | Findings on road safety | Number of crashes by site | p value/significance level reported |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Goh et al. 6 | Before/after analysis | Bogota, Colombia | 10 years | Overall reduction in serious accidents by 50–60 %. Increase of crashes around the stations and where mixed traffic lanes were improved. | 12,449 serious traffic accidents in two sites | Not provided |
Duduta et al. 7 | Before/after analysis | Melbourne, Australia | 3 years | 14 % overall reduction in all road crashes across 56 sites | 160 crashes in the after-period | Significant at 90 % |
Duduta et al. 8 | Modeling of changes in infrastructure | Several BRT systems. Different analyses carried out in each of them. | 3 to 7 years depending on the city | Findings vary across sites. The authors report mixed results with improvements in road safety by 50 % (Guadalajara), as well as deterioration of road safety by 50 % (Delhi). In the count data model, number of legs and lanes per leg, counterflow, level pedestrian crossing and left turns increase the likelihood of collisions. Center medians reduce collisions. |
216 in Mexico City (Mexico); 183 in Porto Alegre (Brazil); 164 in Guadalajara (Mexico); 61 in Bogota (Colombia); 17 in Delhi (India) | p < 0.001 for the findings described in the count data model |
Woodridge 9 | Modeling of changes in infrastructure | Guadalajara, Mexico | 5 years | 56 % reduction in all road crashes, 69 % reduction in severe crashes. | 1010 crashes in the after-period | p < 0.01 |