Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 23;16(9):23035–23056. doi: 10.3390/ijms160923035

Table 1.

General characteristics of the included studies in the meta-analyses. GH: gestational hypertension; SGA: small for gestational age. PTB: preterm birth. The outcomes used were in line with the definitions from International Society for the study of Hypertension (ISSHP) [9].

Study Year GA of Test (Weeks) Biomarker (s) Outcome Study Design A Low/High Risk Location n (Total) n (PE) Level of Evidence
Anderson et al. [10] 2011 11–16 α-1-microglobulin and fetal hemoglobin PE Nested case control (in prospective study) 1 LR UK 96 60 3b
Akolekar et al. [11] 2008 11–14 PlGF, PAPP-A EOPE, LOPE, GH Nested case-control (in trisomy 21 screening cohort) 2 LR + HR UK 824 127 3b
Akolekar et al. [12] 2013 11–14 PlGF, PAPP-A PE Prospective cohort (in screening) LR + HR UK 58,703 1245 1b
Audibert et al. [13] 2010 11–13 PAPP-A, ADAM-12, PlGF, hCG, inhibin-A, PP-13, protein-A, inhibin-A PE, EOPE, LOPE, GH Prospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 3 LR + HR Canada 893 40 1b
Bills et al. [14] 2009 First trimester VEGF(165)b, sFLT, sEng PE, EOPE, LOPE Case-control 4 LR + HR UK 70 25 3b
Bosio et al. [15] 2001 10–14 P-selectin PE, GH Nested case-control (in longitudinal cohort) 5 LR + HR Ireland 70 20 3b
Boucoiran et al. (1) [16] 2013 12–18 PlGF, sFlt-1, inhibin A PE, GH, SGA Prospective cohort (nested in RCT) 6 LR + HR Canada 793 34 1b
Boucoiran et al. (2) [17] 2013 11-14 and 18-22 PlGF, PP-13, ADAM-12 EOPE, LOPE, GH Prospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 7 LR + HR Canada 893 40 1b
Brameld et al. [18] 2008 12 + 3 PAPP-A, free-hCG PE Retrospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 8 LR Australia 22,125 660 2b
Chafetz et al. [19] 2007 9–12 PP-13 PE, PTB, SGA Nested case control in prospective cohort (MOMS-study) 9 LR USA 425 47 3b
Cohen et al. [20] 2014 10–13 PAPP-A, α fetoprotein, free β-hCG PE Nested case control (retrospective cohort) 10 LR + HR USA 2199 148 3b
Cowans et al. [21] 2011 11–14 PP-13 EOPE, LOPE Nested case control (in cohort of trisomy screening) 11 HR UK 234 37 3b
Deurloo et al. [22] 2013 9–14 ADAM-12, PP-13 PE, GH, SGA Nested case control (in cohort of trisomy screening 12 LR + HR The Netherlands 220 17 3b
Dugoff et al. [23] 2004 10–14 PAPP-A PE, PTB, SGA Prospective study (FASTER trial, trisomy screening cohort) 13 LR USA 34,271 764 1b
Giguere et al. [24] 2014 10–18 PlGF, sFlt, PAPP-A, inhibin-A PE Nested case-control (in prospective cohort) 14 LR Canada 648 216 3b
Goetzinger et al. [25] 2013 11–14 ADAM-12, PAPP-A PE, EOPE, LOPE Prospective cohort 15 LR + HR USA 578 54 1b
Gonen et al. [26] 2008 6–10 PP-13 PE, GH Prospective cohort 16 LR + HR Israel 1239 20 1b
Ghosh et al. [27] 2013 11–14 PlGF EOPE Prospective study (screening antenatal care) 17 LR + HR India 1206 9 1b
Hedley et al. [28] 2010 10–14 PAPP-A, free leptin index PE Nested case control (in First Trimester Screening Study) 18 LR Denmark 415 126 3b
Kang et al. [29] 2008 11 and 16 PAPP-A, AFP, uE3, hCG, inhibin-A PE Retrospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 19 LR + HR Korea 3076 32 2b
Kenny et al. [30] 2014 14–16 Multiple PE, EOPE, preterm and term PE Prospective cohort 20 LR Australia/UK/Ireland 5623 278 1b
Khalil et al. [31] 2010 11–14 PP-13 PE, EOPE, PE + SGA Nested case-control (in antenatal clinic cohort) 21 HR UK 252 42 3b
Kuc et al. [32] 2013 9–14 PAPP-A, free -hCG, ADAM-12, PlGF EOPE, LOPE Nested case control (in screening cohort) 22 LR + HR The Netherlands 667 167 3b
Kusanovic et al. [33] 2009 6–15 PlGF, soluble endoglin, sVEGFR-1 EOPE, LOPE Prospective cohort 23 LR Chile 1622 62 3b
Myatt et al. [34] 2012 9–13 ADAM-12, PAPP-A, PP-13, sFLT, endoglin PE Nested case control (in cohort of RCT) 24 LR USA 683 174 2b
Myers et al. [35] 2013 14–16 PlGF, soluble endoglin, sFLT-1 preterm PE (<37 week) Prospective cohort 25 LR Australia/UK/Ireland 235 47 1b
Nicolaides et al. [36] 2006 11–14 PP-13 EOPE Nested case control (in screening cohort) 26 LR + HR UK 433 10 3b
Odibo et al. [37] 2011 11–14 PP13, PAPP-A PE, EOPE Prospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 27 LR + HR USA 452 42 1b
Park et al. [38] 2014 11–14 PAPP-A, PlGF, inhibin-A, sFLT LOPE Prospective cohort 28 LR Korea 262 8 1b
Poon et al. (1) [39] 2009 11–14 PAPP-A PE, EOPE, LOPE Prospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 29 LR + HR UK 8051 156 1b
Poon et al. (2) [40] 2009 11–14 PAPP-A, MMP-9, TNF-R1 EOPE, LOPE, GH, SGA, PTB Nested case-control (in trisomy 21 screening cohort) 30 LR + HR UK 1138 128 3b
Roes et al. [41] 2004 6–15 Inhibin-A PE Case control 31 LR The Netherlands 55 19 3b
Schneuer et al. [42] 2012 11–13 PP-13 PE, EOPE, LOPE, SGA Prospective cohort (trisomy 21 screening cohort) 32 LR + HR Australia 2678 71 1b
Spencer et al. [43] 2006 11–14 PP-13, PAPP-A PE, EOPE, LOPE Nested case-control (in trisomy 21 screening cohort) 33 LR UK 534 88 3b
Spencer et al. [44] 2008 11–14 Inhibin-A and activin-A PE, EOPE, LOPE Nested case-control (in trisomy 21 screening cohort) 34 LR UK 304 64 3b
Tidwell et al. [45] 2001 5–15 PlGF EOPE, LOPE Case control 35 LR Taiwan 39 14 3b
Thilaganathan et al. [46] 2010 14.7 (CO), 16.3 (PE) cystatin-C, CRP PE Nested case-control (in antenatal clinic cohort) 36 LR UK 170 45 3b
Xu et al. [47] 2014 First trimester Chemerin PE Prospective cohort (antenatal care)37 LR China 518 41 1b
Youssef et al. [48] 2011 11–14 PAPP-A, PlGF, sFlt-1, P-selectin, NGAL LOPE Prospective cohort 38 LR + HR Italy 528 13 1b
Yu et al. [49] 2011 12–16 PlGF, inhibin-A, activin-A PE Nested case-control (in antenatal clinic cohort) 39 LR China 124 31 3b
Zong et al. [50] 2012 13–16 Htr-A1 (High-Temperature Requirement A1) PE Prospective cohort (clinical cohort) 40 LR China 1396 100 1b

A Characteristics of the study population are mentioned below; 1 Exclusion criteria diabetes, prepregnancy hypertension and premature delivery; 2 Controls: did not develop any pregnancy complications and resulted in the live birth of phenotypically normal neonates; 3 Exclusion: multiparous, multiple gestation, major fetal chromosomal/structural anomaly; 4 Exclusion: pregnancy induced hypertension, fetal growth restriction, intrauterine death, preterm birth (PTB); 5 Controls: normal obstetric outcome. Matched for body mass index (BMI); 6 Exclusion: vitamin C and/or vitamin E supplements, history of major medical complications, major fetal defects, repeated spontaneous abortion, use of an illicit drug or warfarin treatment during the current pregnancy; 7 Inclusion: nulliparous women with singleton pregnancies without major fetal chromosomal or structural anomaly; 8 Exclusion: Women who had a previous fetus with a chromosomal abnormality and women with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus; 9 Exclusion: AIDS or hepatitis, cases of major fetal anomaly, fetal death and women with placenta previa, placenta accrete, or placental abruption; 10 General population, singleton pregnancies; 11 A priori high risk pregnancies; 12 General population; 13 Inclusion: singleton pregnancy, exclusion: diabetes and chromosomal abnormalities; 14 Exclusion: chronic hepatic or renal diseases, pregnancies with major fetal abnormalities and those ending in termination, miscarriage or fetal death <24 weeks; 15 Exclusion : known aneuploidy and major congenital malformations; 16 Exclusion: miscarriages; 17 Exclusion: congenital abnormalities or medication use; 18 Randomly selected controls; 19 Exclusion: multifetal gestation, diabetes, chromosomal or structural abnormalities; 20 Exclusion: increased risk factors of PE, SGA or PTB, known major fetal anomaly or abnormal karyotype, intervention that may modify pregnancy outcome such as treatment with aspirin or progesterone; 21 Inclusion: history of PE in a previous pregnancy, chronic hypertension, chronic renal disease, antiphospholipid syndrome, systemic lupus erythematosus, pregestational diabetes mellitus, obesity (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m2). Exclusion: multiple pregnancy, cases of major fetal anomaly, miscarriage or fetal death, HIV or hepatitis, placenta previa or placental abruption; 22 Exclusion: multiple pregnancy, delivery <24 weeks, chromosomal abnormalities; 23 Inclusion: pregnancies in which a single live fetus was delivered after 37 complete weeks of gestation with birth weight above the 10th centile and without fetal anomalies; 24 Inclusion: nulliparous, low risk women; 25 Exclusion: increased risk of PE, SGA or PTB, known major fetal anomaly or abnormal karyotype, intervention that may modify pregnancy outcome such as treatment with aspirin or progesterone; 26 Gestational age matched controls; 27 Inclusion : singleton pregnancies. Exclusion: spontaneous miscarriage prior to 20 weeks, loss to follow-up or fetal anomalies diagnosed in the second trimester; 28 Exclusion: high risk pregnancies; 29 Definition controls: randomly selected women without reported pregnancy-associated hypertension; 30 Definition controls: had blood collected and stored on the same day, which did not develop any pregnancy complications and resulted in the live birth of phenotypically normal neonates; 31 Unknown in- and exclusion criteria; 32 Inclusion: singleton pregnancies; 33,34 Gestational age matched controls; 35 Exclusion: multiparity, chronic hypertension, diabetes, multiple gestation, connective tissue disorder, any long-term use of medicine other than prenatal vitamins, and miscarriage before viability; 36 Exclusion: diabetes, connective tissue disease, renal disorders, essential hypertension; 37 Exclusion: previous systemic disorders or drug use, chronic hypertension, diabetes, renal disorders, recent or present fever or infectious disease, malignancies, autoimmune diseases and multiple pregnancies; 38 Exclusion: early-onset PE, multiple gestations, pregnancies with fetal chromosomal or major structural anomaly, miscarriages; 39 Unknown inclusion/exclusion criteria; 40 Exclusion: cases showing intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy, abortion, peripartum cardiomyopathy, and other complications. PlGF: Placental growth factor; PAPP-A: Pregnancy associated plasma protein A; ADAM-12: A disintegrin and metalloprotease 12; CRP: C-reactive protein; hCG: human chorionic gonadotropin; PP-13: Placental protein 13; VEGF: Vascular endothelial growth factor; sFLT: Soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1; sEng: Soluble endoglin; sVEGR-1: Soluble endothelial growth factor-1; uE3: Oestradiol; MMP-9: Matrix metallopeptidase 9; TNF-R1: Tumor-necrosis factor receptor-1; NGAL: Neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin; (1): publication 1 by same author in same year; (2): publication 2 by same author in same year.