Table 2.
Authors | Prospective? | Blinding of Participants | Blinding of Data Collectors | Blinding of Outcome Assessors | ROC Analysis Conducted? | AUC Reported | Threats to Validity | Study Quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kiesel et al15 | No | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | Yes | No | Study methods, statistical methods, statistical reporting | 2/7 |
Kiesel et al16 | Yes | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | No | No | Statistical methods | 2/7 |
Chorba et al3 | Yes | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | No | No | Study methods, statistical methods | 2/7 |
Peate et al28 | Yes | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | Noa | No | Limited | 2/7 |
Butler et al2 | Yes | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | Yes | No | Statistical reporting | 3/7 |
O’Connor et al25 | Yes | Unreported | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Limited | 5/7 |
Shojaedin et al32 | Yes | Unreported | Unreported | Unreported | Yes | No | Statistical reporting | 3/7 |
AUC, area under the curve; ROC, receiver operator characteristic.
Used other statistical methodology to determine cut score.