Skip to main content
. 2015 Mar 23;55(4):267–275. doi: 10.2176/nmc.ra.2014-0317

Table 1.

Overview of the health insurance systems of major OECD countries11)

Japan (2012) Germany (2011) France (2011) Sweden (2010) The United Kingdom (2011) The United States (2011)
Type of system Social insurance system
* Universal health insurance
* Occupational insurance and regional insurance
Social insurance system
* Around 85% of citizens enrolled
* Employees enroll in public health insurance by workplace or by region. Not compulsory for employees over a certain income, self-employed people, civil servants, etc.
* People for whom it is not compulsory are obliged to subscribe to private health insurance (general compulsory enrollment), in effect universal health insurance
Social insurance system
* Universal health insurance (99% of citizens enrolled)
* Enrolled by employee system by workplace or non-employee system (self-employed), etc. (People for whom it is not compulsory subscribe to a universal health system benefit plan.)
Public health and medical services through the tax system
* For all residents
* Landstinger (regional governments) are the providing entities (cash benefits are implemented nationally)
State-owned National Health Service (NHS) through the tax system
* For all residents
Social insurance system (Medicare/Medicaid)
* Medicare targets those over 65 and persons with disabilities; Medicaid targets low-income earners who meet certain criteria
* Does not constitute universal health insurance [16.3% (2010) of the population not covered by any health insurance at all], large role played by the private sector
Individual contribution 30% Pre-compulsory education: 20%
70–74 years: 20% (30% for those on par with active income earners)
75 years or older: 10% (30% for those on par with active income earners)
- Outpatient : €10 examination fees per quarter for the same illness (free of charge for people with referrals)
- Inpatient : €10 per day (up to 28 days per year)
- Medication: 10% fixed rate (maximum expenses €10, minimum €5)
- Outpatient : 30%
- Inpatient : 20%
- Medication: 35%
(0% for anti-cancer agents and other expensive medications with no alternatives; 70% for stomach medicines; 85% for less-useful medications; 100% for vitamins and tonics)
* Reimbursement system requiring full payment up front (however, in-kind benefits are paid for hospitalization, etc.)
* Supplementary medical costs insurance has been developed to cover individual contributions. (Mutual aid association format; 80% of citizens enrolled.)
* In addition to the above fixed rates, there is an outpatient contribution (€1 per day, maximum €50 per calendar year) and an inpatient fixed contribution (€18 per day, €13,5 for psychiatry)
These cannot be reimbursed by supplementary medical costs insurance.
Inpatient : Set independently by each landstinger at about 80 kr as the daily maximum.
* In many landstinger , free of charge to those aged 18–20 years
Outpatient: Set independently by each landstinger
Individual contribution for primary care can be 100–200 kr per time (By law, the maximum individual patient contribution nationwide is 900 kr per year; landstinger can set a lower amount than this.)
- In many landstinger , free of charge for persons below 20 years of age.
- Medication: Fully self-paid up to the maximum individual contribution of 900 kr (Maximum of 1,800 kr per year.)
No individual contribution principle
* Outpatient prescription medication has a fixed amount per prescription; three types of fixed-amount contributions for dental treatment.
Further exemptions for elderly, low income earners, pregnant women, etc.
There are many exemptions for medications.
Inpatient : (Part A) Medicare (compulsory enrollment) 60 days from admission: individual contribution up to $1156 61–90 days: $289/day 91–150 days: $578/day 151+ days: full amount
- Outpatient : (Part B) (optional enrollment) $155 per year + 20% of medical expenses
- Medication: (Part D) (optional enrollment) Up to $310: full amount self-paid $310–2,830: 25%
$2830–4550: full amount self-paid $4,550+: 5%
Funding Premiums 10% of remuneration (half paid by the employer)
* Japan Health Insurance Association
15.5% of remuneration Individual: 8.2%
Employer: 7.3%
* Common to all insured persons
* Self-employed persons: individual pays the full amount
13.85% of total wages
Individual: 0.75%
Employer: 13.1%
* Employee health insurance system enrolled in by private merchants (general system)
Nil Nil
* More than 20% of NHS costs are appropriated from national insurance premiums for cash benefits, such as retirement pensions, etc.
Inpatient (Part A)
2.9% of salary (half paid by the employer)
* Self-employed persons: individual pays the full amount
Outpatient (Part B)
Around $115.40 per month (individual pays the full amount)
Medication (Part D)
(average premium)
Around $40.72 per month (individual pays the full amount)
State contribution 16.4% of benefit expenses, etc.
* Japan Health Insurance Association
By law, set at €4 billion in 2009 and to increase by €1.5 billion each year until it reaches a total of €14 billion.
Under secondary economic measures, set in January 2009, associated with the economic and financial crisis, €3.2 billion (€6.3 billion based on a full fiscal year) was injected, as the premium rate was set to be reduced by 0.6% in July 2009.
Accordingly, the maximum of €14 billion is expected to be reached in 2012.
Traditionally, state liability was limited to making up deficits; however, the state contribution increased in 1991. Appropriated from general public contributions (purposed tax) to fund medical care, pensions, etc. (Tax rate: 7.5% of wage income, including 5.29% medical portion)
* Employee insurance system funding breakdown (2008)
- Premiums: about 56%
- General public contributions: about 37%
- Other purposed tax (tobacco, alcohol, etc.): about 5%
No such principle.
* Covered by landstinger tax revenues (residents’ income tax, etc.) and individual patient contribution amounts.
* Small general allocation taxes and subsidies are available from the national government.
Financed by taxes. Inpatient (Part A)
Financed by social security tax
Outpatient (Part B)
Around 75% of costs
Medication (Part D)
Around 75% of costs