Table 1.
Studies of osteochondral allograft to treat femoral condyle articular cartilage lesions
| Author | Year | No. of subjects | Follow-up | Graft type | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Levy et al. [29••] | 2013 | 129 | 13.5 years | Fresh | - 82 % graft survival at 10 years |
| - 66 % graft survival at 20 years | |||||
| - 24 % failed at mean 7.2 years | |||||
| - Merle d’Aubugne-Postel score increased from 12.1 to 16 | |||||
| - IKDC function score increased from 3.4 to 7.2 | |||||
| Laprade et al. [14] | 2009 | 23 | 3 years | Fresh | - 100 % graft survival |
| - IKDC subjective score improved from 52 to 68.5 | |||||
| Davidson et al. [30] | 2007 | 10 | 40 months | Fresh | - IKDC subjective score improved from 27 to 79 |
| - Tegner activity level increased from 4.3 to 5.3 | |||||
| Emmerson et al. [31] | 2007 | 65 | 7.7 years | Fresh | - 85 % graft survival |
| - Merle d’Aubugne-Postel score improved from 13.0 to 16.4 | |||||
| - 86 % satisfaction with results | |||||
| Aubin et al. [32] | 2001 | 60 | 10 years | Fresh | - 85 % graft survival at 10 years |
| - 74 % graft survival at 15 years | |||||
| - Mean Hospital for Special Surgery Score 83 points at 10 years | |||||
| Garrett et al. [33] | 1994 | 17 | 2–9 years | Fresh | - 94 % graft survival |
| Marco et al. [34] | 1993 | 15 | 3.2 years | Fresh, frozen | - 86.6 % graft survival |