Table I.
Producer | Roche | Illumina/Solexa | Life Technologies | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Platform | 454 GS FLX | 454 GS Junior | GAII | HISeq models | MiSeq | SOLiD | Ion Torrent | Ion Proton |
Seq method | SBS Pyro | SBS Pyro | SBS RDT | SBS RDT | SBS RDT | SBS | SBS H+ | SBS H+ |
Amplification | emPCR | emPCR | Bridge PCR | Bridge PCR | Bridge PCR | emPCR | emPCR | emPCR |
Read length | 400–700 bp* | 400 bp | 36–151 bp | up to 2×150 bp** | 36–151 bp | 35–75 bp | > 100 bp***** | up to 200 bp |
Type of read | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE | SE, PE |
Output Gb/run | 0.45 – 0.7 | 0.35 | ≤ 95 | up to 600*** | > 1 | 77–155**** | > 1***** | up to 10 |
Run time | up to 24 h | 10 h | 2–14 days | 27h to 11 days | 4–27 h | 2–7 days | 2 h | 2–4 h |
Error rate (%) | 1 | 1 | ≥0.1 | ≥0.1 | >0.1 | >0.01 | ~1 | |
Error type | Indels | Indels | Substitutions | Substitutions | Substitutions | Substitutions | Indels | |
Cost of machine | up to $ 500k | Approx $115k | approx $ 540k | up to $740k | approx $128k | $525k | approx $80k | approx $150k |
Pros | Longer reads, faster | Good read length, fast | Widely used, mature platform | Ultra high output, ease of use | Fully automated workflow | Ultra high output, scalable runs; can use 96 bar codes | Cheap, past, label free chemistry, highly scalable | WGS applications, 384 barcodes supported by the Torrent Suite Software |
Cons | High cost per Mb, errors with homo polymer repeats | Like the FLX, plus lowest output among small sequencing instruments | High cost per Mb, low multiplexing capabilities | Less scalability, high overall costs | Insufficiently used | Shorter read length, long time for clonal preparation | Homopolymer errors, laborious (yet semi-automated) library preparation | Possibly high cost per Mb and errors |
SBS = Sequencing by synthesis; SBL = Sequencing by ligation; RDT = Reverse dye terminator; SE = Single-ended read; PE = Paired-ended read
at the lower limit of the range for the Titanium
PE for the 1500 and 2500 on rapid run
for the 2000 and 2500 on high output
155 Gb for the XL model
for the 318 chip