Table 1.
Methods | Pros | Cons | Suggestions/Comments |
---|---|---|---|
Passive micromixers | |||
Stream splitting and recombination |
Basic, but more effective than pure diffusive mixing |
May require long channels for complex micromixer network |
Pay careful attention to the method of recombination; adequate mixing may result without additional elements. |
Slanted wells or patterned grooves |
Easy to fabricate (no moving parts), CFD code available for optimization |
Requires additional fabrication to adjust the level of mixing |
Useful for mixing enhancement when precise control is not required. |
Hydrophobicity or surface modification |
Additional mixing enhancement over other passive mixers |
May be complicated to define surface modification zones |
Combining with other passive mixers to maximize mixing potential |
Multiphase mixing enhancement |
Low fabrication cost, good mixing with little sample dilution, and large mixing property change by adjusting flow rates |
Requires additional purification step as immiscible carrier liquids or gas must be introduced into the device |
Consider for use if introducing an additional fluid into a device is possible without hindering device operation. |
Active micromixers | |||
Microstirrers | Versatile; excellent mixing with precise control |
Difficult to fabricate (moving parts); may require multiple stirrers |
Useful for applications requiring precise control over the level of mixing; magnetic actuation easier than mechanical actuation. Utilizing magnetic particles may offset some of the fabrication difficulties. |
Acoustic waves | Nearly instantaneous mixing; easy to operate |
Need a bubble or air interface | Consider acoustic mixers if quick mixing is needed |
Flow pulsation | Easy to implement using micropumps or electric fields |
Requires fine-tuning to achieve optimal mixing enhancement |
Convenient when pumps are integrated or do not compromise operation |
Thermal enhancement | Simple to integrate into a device | Requires heaters | Consider thermal micromixers where heat does not affect samples/reagents |
Electrokinetic mixing enhancement |
Can be utilized effectively at relatively low voltages. Can be very effective over short mixing lengths. |
Requires integrated electrodes | Consider when electrodes are integrated into the device. Utilize ac voltages to avoid bubble formation. |