Table 3.
Intensity and Trial, Year | Structured Home Visits | Telephone Follow-up | Clinic Follow-up | Telecare Only | Telecare + Other Types of Follow-up | Details |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Low intensity | ||||||
Riegel et al,37 2006 | X | 11 RCTs had a prearranged telephone follow-up.37–44,53,56,62 Patients received 3 to 16 telephone calls (over a 2- to 12-month period). | ||||
Domingues et al,56 2011 | X | |||||
DeBusk et al,38 2004 | X | |||||
Laramee et al,39 2003 | X | |||||
Wakefield et al,40 2008 | X | |||||
Dunagan et al,41 2005 | X | |||||
Rainville et al,42 1999 | X | |||||
Tsuyuki et al,53 2004 | X | |||||
Barth et al,43 2001 | X | |||||
Lopez Cabezas et al,62 2006 | X | |||||
Chaudhry et al,44 2010 | X | |||||
Doughty et al,70 2002 | X | In 2 RCTs, follow-up was provided in an outpatient clinic by the family physician or a cardiologist or multidisciplinary team.56,69 Patients visited the clinic7 to 10 times (over a 12- to 18-month period). | ||||
Jaarsma et al,57 2008 | X | |||||
Moderate intensity | ||||||
Stewart et al,9 1998; Inglis et al,81 2004 | X | 4 RCTs used prearranged home visits9,34,70,71 with a total of 2 to 9 visits (over a 6- to 12-month period). | ||||
Barker et al,71 2012 | X | |||||
Naylor et al,35 2004 | X | |||||
Kwok et al,72 2008 | X | |||||
Nucifora et al,59 2006 | X | X | 8 RCTs combined a structured telephone call with follow-up in a clinic.44,45,53,57–59,62,63 They included 1 to 10 telephone calls and 1 to 8 visits to the clinic (over a 6- to 24-month period). | |||
Del Sindaco et al,60 2007 | X | X | ||||
Cleland et al,58 2005 | X | X | ||||
Ekman et al,64 1998 | X | X | ||||
Atienza et al,63 2004 | X | X | ||||
Kasper et al,45 2002 | X | X | ||||
Angermann et al,46 2012 | X | X | ||||
Ducharme et al,54 2005 | X | X | ||||
Dar et al,66 2009 | X | 2 RCTs featured telecare without prearranged direct contact with patients.47,66 The vital signs transmit-ted daily consisted of weight,47,66 blood pressure, pulse, and oxygen saturation.66 Patients also answered questions on CHF symptoms via telephone (automated voice response).47,66 | ||||
Goldberg et al,47 2002 | X | |||||
High intensity | ||||||
Harrison et al,55 2002 | X | X | 6 RCTs used structured home visits combined with telephone follow-up.8,10,47,54,66,67 Patients had a total of 1 to 3 home visits (over a 3- to 12-month period). | |||
Rich et al,48 1993 | X | X | ||||
Rich et al,8 1995 | X | X | ||||
Blue et al,67 2001 | X | X | ||||
Leventhal et al,68 2011 | X | X | ||||
Jaarsma et al,10 1999 | X | X | ||||
Cline et al,65 1998 | X | X | 2 RCTs combined home visits with follow-up in a clinic.64,72 Patients received 1 home visit and 4 to 6 in-clinic follow-ups (over a 6- to 12-month period). | |||
Thompson et al,73 2005 | X | X | ||||
Adlbrecht et al,69 2011; Berger et al,82 2010 | X | X | X | 3 RCTs combined home visits with telephone calls and a visit to a clinic.48,56,68 The total number of home visits ranged from 1 to 3 (over a 3- to 12-month period). | ||
Pugh et al,49 2001; Blaha et al,83 2000 | X | X | X | |||
Jaarsma et al,57 2008 | X | X | X | |||
Giordano et al,61 2009 | X | 5 RCTs combined telecare with prearranged direct contact with patients50–52,58,61 such as prearranged telephone calls,51,61 video calls and home visits,50,52 or visits to a clinic.58 Vital signs (weight, blood pressure, oxygen saturation, heart sounds, pulse, and electrocardiographic findings) were transmitted daily50,51,58 or at a scheduled time.52,61 | ||||
Bowles et al,50 2011 | X | |||||
Kulshreshtha et al,51 2010 | X | |||||
Pekmezaris et al,52 2012 | X | |||||
Cleland et al,58 2005 | X |
CHF = congestive heart failure; RCT = randomized controlled trial.