Table 3.
Author | Study Design, Country |
Subjects | Strength of Association |
---|---|---|---|
LATERALITY OF MOTOR SYMPTOMS | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between laterality of motor signs and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Foster et al (2011) | Case control study USA |
Patients of the Movement Disorders Center | Patients of the Movement Disorders Center |
CLINICAL FEATURES | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between PD clinical features (akinetic rigid vs. tremor dominant) and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Henderson et al (1992) | Empirical study with self report questionnaire USA |
Community –dwelling older adults | Motor fluctuations associated with increase likelihood of depression and anxiety self report Association found between motor state and depression and anxiety disorders (r= 0.56, p<0.001) |
SEVERITY OF PD | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between the severity of the disease and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Menza et al (1993) | Case control study USA |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Clinic | Significant correlations were found between RDRS-2 and GDS (r= 0.48, p<0.01), Zung (r= 0.59, p<0.001), and SAS (r= 0.50, p<0.001) Correlation found between H/Y and SAS (r= 0.36, p<0.05), GDS (r= 0.41, p<0.01), and Zung (r= 0.39, p<0.01) |
Henderson et al (1992) | Empirical study with self report questionnaire USA |
Community –dwelling older adults | Association found between frequency of symptoms and depression and anxiety disorders (r= 0.66, p<0.0001) |
PD ONSET | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between age of PD onset and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Henderson et al (1992) | Empirical study with self report questionnaire USA |
Community –dwelling older adults | Association found between PD onset and depression and anxiety disorders (r= 0.74, p<0.001) |
PD DURATION | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between disease duration and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Foster et al (2011) | Case control study USA |
Patients of the Movement Disorders Center | Significant positive correlations between PD duration and severity of depressive and anxiety symptoms [GDS (r=0.496, p=0.002), BDI-II (r=0.439, p=0.006) and the STAIS (r=0.417, p=0.009)] among RHO patients |
ANTIPARKINSON THERAPY | |||
Nuti et al (2004) | Quantitative case control study Italy |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Unit | No correlation was found between PD pharmacological therapy and the prevalence of mood and anxiety disorders |
Menza et al (1993) | Case control study USA |
Outpatients of the Movement Disorders Clinic | No significant association was found between anti- Parkinson medications and depression and anxiety disorders |
AUTONOMIC SYMPTOMS | |||
Berrios et al (1995) | Prospective case control study Great Britain |
Subjects from the University of Cambridge Department of Psychiatry Parkinson’s Disease Project Database | Significant correlations were found between autonomic symptoms and depression (HRSD, P<0.01) and anxiety disorders (HRSA, P<0.01) |
Note. BDI-II= Beck Depression Inventory-II; GDS= Geriatric depression scale; HRSA= Hamilton Rating Scales for Anxiety; HRSD= Hamilton Rating Scales for Depression; H/Y staging= Hoehn and Yahr staging system; LHO= left hemibody onset of symptoms; RDRS-2=Rapid Disability Rating Scale-2; RHO= right hemibody onset of symptoms; SAS= Zung Self-Administered Anxiety Questionnaire; STAI or STAIS= State-Trait Anxiety Inventory State; Zung= Zung Depression Questionnaire