Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Health Phys. 2016 Jan;110(1):74–92. doi: 10.1097/HP.0000000000000406

Table 4.

Consistency of answers between two interviews and thyroid doses due to 131I intakes.

Characteristics Total Pairs of respondents

Subject-subject Subject-mother Subject-other relative Mother-to mother Mother-other relative Other relative-other relative

Agreed (%) κ (rs)a Agreed (%) κ (rs) Agreed (%) κ (rs) Agreed (%) κ (rs) Agreed (%) κ (rs) Agreed (%) κ (rs) Agreed (%) κ (rs)
Residential history
Name of settlement ATA b 88 - 91 - 85 - 86 - 89 - 87 - 84 -
  < 10 y c 87 - 88 - 85 - 84 - 89 - 87 - 84 -
  10-18 y c 92 - 92 - 79 - 90 - 100 - 92 - 100 -
  Male d 88 - 91 - 85 - 86 - 88 - 88 - 84 -
  Female d 88 - 91 - 85 - 85 - 89 - 87 - 85 -
  Rural e 91 - 93 - 88 - 89 - 91 - 89 - 89 -
  Urban e 82 - 83 - 81 - 75 - 85 - 85 - 85 -
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 90 - 92 - 85 - 86 - 90 - 88 - 81 -
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 87 - 90 - 86 - 86 - 88 - 86 - 79 -

Number of settlements of residence 48 0.55 51 0.64 42 0.40 44 0.47 55 0.65 46 0.50 50 0.59
  < 10 y 47 0.50 52 0.58 42 0.39 42 0.41 55 0.65 46 0.50 50 0.59
  10-18 y 51 0.64 51 0.65 42 0.53 49 0.56 54 0.86 42 0.36 50 NA f
  Male 48 0.54 52 0.63 41 0.36 41 0.43 55 0.65 44 0.51 46 0.55
  Female 49 0.56 51 0.65 43 0.43 46 0.50 55 0.65 49 0.49 55 0.66
  Rural 49 0.56 53 0.67 41 0.37 45 0.49 54 0.66 46 0.52 50 0.58
  Urban 48 0.52 46 0.55 45 0.48 43 0.40 57 0.60 47 0.46 54 0.61
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 51 0.60 54 0.67 40 0.37 48 0.57 59 0.70 42 0.46 47 0.45
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 44 0.46 49 0.58 41 0.38 39 0.34 52 0.60 43 0.48 52 0.64

Date of first relocation g 42 0.329 44 0.326 37 0.283 35 0.268 50 0.411 39 0.295 36 0.327
  < 10 y 40 0.299 36 0.282 36 0.281 30 0.226 50 0.411 40 0.330 35 0.325
  10-18 y 46 0.325 46 0.333 41 0.349 46 0.342 43 0.500 10 -0.268 100 NA
  Male 43 0.323 44 0.295 38 0.306 34 0.239 51 0.435 39 0.273 33 0.263
  Female 42 0.333 45 0.349 35 0.264 36 0.290 49 0.388 40 0.307 39 0.401
  Rural 43 0.279 45 0.301 36 0.186 37 0.240 50 0.358 41 0.242 37 0.285
  Urban 39 0.318 37 0.269 37 0.272 30 0.167 48 0.448 38 0.329 38 0.249
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 44 0.338 44 0.335 37 0.267 40 0.303 51 0.456 31 0.225 42 0.278
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 40 0.246 44 0.224 38 0.228 30 0.182 48 0.331 41 0.253 37 0.232

Name of settlement of first relocation 49 - 47 - 46 - 41 - 61 - 47 - 47 -
  < 10 y 51 - 47 - 46 - 40 - 61 - 47 - 47 -
  10-18 y 47 - 47 - 46 - 44 - 43 - 50 - 100 -
  Male 48 - 44 - 48 - 40 - 59 - 47 - 48 -
  Female 50 - 49 - 45 - 42 - 63 - 48 - 46 -
  Rural 46 - 45 - 37 - 38 - 55 - 39 - 46 -
  Urban 57 - 57 - 65 - 52 - 73 - 67 - 57 -
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 51 - 47 - 51 - 52 - 68 - 43 - 45 -
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 43 - 41 - 41 - 29 - 55 - 45 - 37 -

Residential history for evacuees
 Name of settlement ATA 85 - 89 - 78 - 85 - 85 - 90 - 76 -
 Number of settlements 36 0.336 39 0.371 29 0.198 27 0.220 52 0.643 30 0.389 33 -0.182
 Date of evacuation e 49 0.292 45 0.236 45 0.195 48 0.222 66 0.472 51 NA 53 NA
 Name of settlement after evacuation 46 - 49 - 41 - 41 - 59 - 40 - 37 -

Cow milk consumption
  Source of milk 56 0.381 62 0.447 45 0.271 53 0.330 60 0.449 53 0.352 53 0.337
  < 10 y 51 0.337 54 0.362 45 0.267 48 0.276 60 0.450 52 0.346 52 0.341
  10-18 y 65 0.476 65 0.472 57 0.402 71 0.527 86 0.811 92 0.875 50 NA
  Male 55 0.370 60 0.397 45 0.274 51 0.299 62 0.481 55 0.370 55 0.353
  Female 56 0.392 65 0.488 45 0.269 56 0.359 58 0.422 51 0.338 50 0.319
  Rural 55 0.323 63 0.389 42 0.194 56 0.283 59 0.405 52 0.286 52 0.284
  Urban 57 0.371 61 0.365 53 0.318 49 0.278 62 0.470 53 0.339 52 0.348
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 60 0.427 64 0.456 49 0.324 53 0.318 61 0.468 52 0.347 56 0.370
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 50 0.312 59 0.401 42 0.235 50 0.294 60 0.431 54 0.352 48 0.256

Consumption rate ATA of privately owned cow milk 54 0.334 56 0.395 49 0.218 49 0.271 59 0.393 53 0.304 55 0.313
  < 10 y 52 0.288 52 0.316 49 0.214 46 0.230 59 0.393 53 0.304 55 0.318
  10-18 y 56 0.409 56 0.411 61 0.374 52 0.371 57 0.323 58 0.259 0 NA
  Male 51 0.314 52 0.351 48 0.204 46 0.240 59 0.392 52 0.299 56 0.347
  Female 55 0.349 60 0.425 50 0.231 50 0.295 59 0.394 55 0.306 53 0.250
  Rural 47 0.277 51 0.344 40 0.157 43 0.222 52 0.322 45 0.223 45 0.228
  Urban 73 0.310 77 0.267 70 0.251 70 0.142 74 0.443 71 0.303 84 0.462
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 54 0.353 55 0.388 49 0.194 47 0.253 62 0.420 49 0.239 64 0.420
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 49 0.278 53 0.373 47 0.212 45 0.234 53 0.329 53 0.309 45 0.237

Consumption rate of privately owned cow milk h 53 0.327 56 0.382 47 0.215 47 0.248 58 0.410 51 0.308 52 0.303
  < 10 y 51 0.287 52 0.289 47 0.211 46 0.228 59 0.408 52 0.305 52 0.300
  10-18 y 56 0.399 57 0.403 57 0.350 48 0.291 86 0.774 75 0.561 50 NA
  Male 51 0.303 50 0.327 45 0.198 43 0.210 61 0.426 52 0.309 51 0.298
  Female 55 0.347 60 0.427 48 0.230 49 0.280 58 0.393 52 0.304 54 0.302
  Rural 48 0.279 52 0.341 40 0.163 42 0.200 55 0.350 46 0.229 46 NA
  Urban 66 0.373 70 0.365 61 0.306 64 0.331 69 0.474 66 0.395 68 0.332
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 54 0.345 56 0.385 47 0.190 45 0.222 62 0.430 45 0.174 58 0.365
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 49 0.279 55 0.389 46 0.209 46 0.254 53 0.328 52 0.309 44 0.225

Consumption rate ATA of milk from a commercial trade network 75 0.427 80 0.500 70 0.372 77 0.373 75 0.417 74 0.356 77 0.384
  < 10 y 72 0.388 77 0.435 70 0.372 75 0.323 75 0.417 74 0.351 77 0.381
  10-18 y 80 0.515 81 0.519 59 0.330 85 0.554 57 0.344 75 0.571 100 NA
  Male 75 0.410 79 0.472 68 0.365 76 0.326 74 0.415 75 0.354 77 0.306
  Female 76 0.442 80 0.522 71 0.378 79 0.419 75 0.419 73 0.355 78 0.469
  Rural 83 0.381 87 0.465 77 0.294 86 0.313 81 0.375 84 0.324 87 0.422
  Urban 53 0.283 52 0.246 53 0.281 48 0.188 60 0.351 48 0.194 50 0.198
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 78 0.474 82 0.536 69 0.385 79 0.356 75 0.424 75 0.399 77 0.313
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 74 0.386 78 0.460 71 0.362 77 0.348 76 0.438 73 0.308 78 0.336

Consumption rate of milk from a commercial trade networkh 61 0.308 66 0.368 54 0.240 62 0.262 61 0.331 57 0.267 60 0.227
  < 10 y 59 0.282 68 0.366 55 0.241 61 0.217 61 0.331 59 0.261 62 0.231
  10-18 y 66 0.367 67 0.368 47 0.181 70 0.419 57 0.417 75 0.532 50 NA
  Male 59 0.280 62 0.300 53 0.232 61 0.263 61 0.330 58 0.258 63 0.215
  Female 63 0.333 70 0.425 56 0.246 63 0.259 62 0.332 59 0.237 61 0.239
  Rural 65 0.257 70 0.310 57 0.154 67 0.037 64 0.314 62 0.238 64 0.217
  Urban 50 0.214 52 0.197 49 0.201 45 0.212 55 0.282 45 0.131 47 0.206
  Time between interviews < 2.1 y 66 0.370 70 0.405 57 0.221 66 0.315 64 0.380 60 0.310 66 0.219
  Time between interviews ≥ 5.0 y 57 0.248 59 0.268 54 0.315 60 0.218 60 0.323 56 0.249 54 0.136

Milk products consumption
 Consumption rate of milk products 34 0.099 38 0.131 26 0.043 30 0.090 41 0.149 27 0.016 25 0.059

Leafy vegetables consumption
 Date of beginning of consumption 31 0.051 34 0.052 28 0.045 33 0.083 27 0.061 22 -0.002 29 -0.019
 Date of ending of consumption 31 0.066 32 0.073 34 0.099 27 0.053 28 0.013 27 0.089 18 -0.088
 Consumption rate 41 0.142 30 0.104 39 0.072 38 0.079 60 0.241 51 0.109 55 0.160

Stable iodine administration
 Yes/No 75 0.487 77 0.539 71 0.389 68 0.553 79 0.433 73 0.433 75 0.420
 Date of beginning 26 0.208 26 0.181 24 0.165 26 0.267 28 0.298 21 0.153 31 0.343
 Duration 43 0.203 44 0.223 42 0.168 37 0.129 45 0.210 41 0.134 54 0.351

Thyroid dose from 131I intakes i
 Ecological dose 51 0.260 51 0.254 48 0.244 50 0.220 58 0.281 51 0.233 54 0.304
  Inhalation of 131I 93 0.855 93 0.866 92 0.836 90 0.829 93 0.871 91 0.853 89 0.826
  Intake of 131I in milk 42 0.243 43 0.244 36 0.206 38 0.174 51 0.300 41 0.224 40 0.185
  Intake of 131I in milk products 25 0.172 31 0.198 18 0.131 23 0.130 29 0.203 22 0.108 19 NA
  Intake of 131I in leafy vegetables 10 0.124 15 0.109 6 0.078 8 0.105 8 0.173 6 0.082 9 0.215
 Instrumental dose 96 0.809 97 0.826 95 0.788 96 0.808 95 0.812 96 0.778 97 0.813
a

κ-coefficient or Spearman's rank-correlation coefficient, which is shown in Italic, provide measure of agreement.

b

ATA = at the time of the accident.

c

Age of the study subject at the time of the accident.

d

Gender of the study subject.

e

Type of place of residence at the time of the accident.

f

κ-coefficient cannot be calculated because of different number of categories of responses.

g

Exact date, date ± 1 day, or period.

h

Consumption rate averaged over the period from 26 April through 10 May 1986.

i

Two values of doses were considered to agree if they differ less than 50%.