Table 4. pH, the Hunter Lab attributes and TBA value of meatballs formulated with different levels of bee pollen.
Bee pollen level (%) | Storage time (d) |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 3 | 6 | 9 | ||
pH | Control | 6.58±0.02aA | 6.57±0.03bA | 5.98±0.03aB | 5.56±0.04bC |
1.5 | 6.51±0.02bB | 6.61±0.01aA | 5.70±0.05dC | 5.76±0.07aC | |
3.0 | 6.48±0.02bB | 6.59±0.01abA | 5.79±0.03cC | 5.47±0.02cD | |
4.5 | 6.34±0.03cB | 6.49±0.03cA | 5.96±0.05abC | 5.71±0.02aD | |
6.0 | 6.37±0.01cA | 6.40±0.02dA | 5.91±0.04bB | 5.59±0.02bC | |
Hunter L1) | Control | 53.47±3.01ab | 55.29±1.03a | 52.48±1.05b | 55.77±0.42a |
1.5 | 55.59±2.62a | 56.07±1.15a | 56.60±0.45a | 54.71±0.42a | |
3.0 | 54.47±1.32a | 53.19±0.55b | 55.45±0.34a | 55.47±2.14a | |
4.5 | 52.00±1.06ab | 52.43±0.98b | 50.66v0.69c | 51.71±0.13b | |
6.0 | 49.81±0.86bA | 51.47±1.35bA | 47.53±1.51dB | 49.49±0.35cAB | |
Hunter a2) | Control | 9.94±1.49aB | 8.82±0.99aB | 11.74±0.33aA | 9.58±0.03aB |
1.5 | 6.79±0.64bD | 8.69±0.61aC | 10.66±0.25aA | 9.70±0.24aB | |
3.0 | 7.15±0.78bB | 6.02±0.62bC | 9.23±1.18bA | 7.53±0.28bB | |
4.5 | 6.59±0.21bB | 4.95±0.32bcC | 7.38±0.39cA | 7.47±0.37bA | |
6.0 | 6.39±0.63bB | 4.340±.48cC | 7.68±0.19cA | 7.41±0.33bA | |
Hunter b3) | Control | 11.74±0.72cA | 11.56±0.48cA | 10.54±0.62cB | 10.19±0.12dB |
1.5 | 15.05±0.50b | 15.57±0.37b | 15.61±0.62b | 14.74±0.51c | |
3.0 | 18.10±1.09a | 16.67±0.92b | 17.26±0.76a | 17.21±0.93b | |
4.5 | 18.64±1.43a | 18.28±0.50a | 17.89±0.46a | 18.08±0.74ab | |
6.0 | 18.92±0.53aA | 19.27±0.87aA | 17.39±0.15aB | 18.71±0.23aA | |
TBA4) | Control | 0.44±0.04D | 0.58±0.05aC | 0.66±0.03aB | 0.79±0.01aA |
1.5 | 0.41±0.08B | 0.48±0.03bB | 0.56±0.03bA | 0.60±0.01bA | |
3.0 | 0.38±0.06C | 0.44±0.02cB | 0.54±0.03bA | 0.55±0.04cA | |
4.5 | 0.38±0.03C | 0.40±0.04cdC | 0.45±0.01cB | 0.53±0.01cA | |
6.0 | 0.34±0.01 | 0.36±0.03d | 0.36±0.06d | 0.38±0.02d |
Values are means standard deviation of three replicates.
a-dMeans in the same column with different superscript letters are different (p<0.05).
A-DMeans in the same row with different superscript letters are different (p<0.05).
1)Hunter L=Lightness (100=white, 0=black).
2)Hunter a=Redness (+, red; −, green).
3)Hunter b=Yellowness (+, yellow; −, blue).
4)TBA=Tthiobarbituric acid (mg MDA/kg sample).