Table 3.
Study | Subject population | Control for IQ | Control for SES | Type of assignment | Control interventions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bolduc and Lefebvre, 2012 | Typical | Yes | SES not reported | Random assignment by class | Phonological control |
Cogo-Moreira et al., 2013 | Atypical | Yes | SES not reported | Random assignment by school | No-treatment control |
Degé and Schwarzer, 2011 | Typical | Yes | Yes | Student random | Non-auditory control (sports) |
Gromko, 2005 | Typical | IQ not reported | No | Non-random assignment by school | No-treatment control |
Herrera et al., 2011, Spanish | Typical | Yes | SES not reported | Student random | Phonological control |
Herrera et al., 2011, Tamazight | Typical | Yes | SES not reported | Student random | Phonological control |
Moreno et al., 2009 | Typical | Yes | Yes | Student random | Non-auditory control (art) |
Moreno et al., 2011 | Typical | Yes | Yes | Student random | Non-auditory control (art) |
Moritz et al., 2013 | Typical | Yes | No | Non-random assignment by school | Less intensive music control |
Myant et al., 2008 | Typical | IQ not reported | Yes | Non-random assignment by school | No-treatment control |
Register, 2004 | Typical | IQ not reported | Yes | Non-random assignment by class | No-treatment control |
Thomson et al., 2013 | Atypical | Yes | SES not reported | Student random | No-treatment control |
Yazejian and Peisner-Feinberg, 2009 | Typical | IQ not reported | Yes | Random assignment by class | No-treatment control |
This table reports population, IQ, SES, type of assignment, and control interventions for each study.