Skip to main content
. 2015 Oct 17;43(21):10168–10179. doi: 10.1093/nar/gkv1039

Table 1. Summary of secondary structure predictions.

Prediction number Software Method Comparative SHAPE data Max. contact distance = 600 nt
1 RNAstructure Thermod. NO YES YES
2 RNAstructure Thermod. NO NO YES
3 PPfold 3.1 SCFG YES YES NO
4 PPfold 3.1 SCFG YES NO NO
5 GTfold (Aug 2011) Thermod. NO NO NO
6 GTfold (Aug 2011) Thermod. NO YES NO
7 GTfold (Aug 2011) Thermod. NO NO YES
8 GTfold (Aug 2011) Thermod. NO YES YES
9 UNAfold Thermod. NO NO NO
10 UNAfold Thermod. NO NO YES
11 PETfold Combin. YES NO NO
12 RNAalifold Thermod. YES NO NO
13 PPfold 3.1 SCFG YES YES (re-normalized) NO

Prediction 1 is identical to the structure published in (7). In SHAPE-driven predictions, unless otherwise indicated, the SHAPE data published in (7) were used without re-normalization. The details for re-normalization used for prediction 13 are described in Supplementary Methods. In phylogenetic predictions, the manually curated HIV-1 alignment, described in Materials and Methods, was used. The full pairing schemes are provided in Supplementary Table S1.