Skip to main content
. 2015 Dec 7;10(12):e0144305. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0144305

Table 1. Comparison of hybrid assemblies obtained from various long-read correction tools.

Assembly No. of contigs Largest contig Total length NGA50 No. of misassemblies No. of mismatches a No. of indels a Genome fraction (%) No. of genes Overall runtime
Escherichia coli K12 MG1655 (genome size = 4636675 bp, No. of genes = 4497)
Abyss 82 285832 4646776 129004 2 2.92 0.41 99.48 4426 60m
LoRDEC + runCA 47 4188310 4791407 686189 43 3.30 0.65 100.00 4494 15h 46m
LSC + runCA 29 1954248 4769525 572337 21 2.26 0.54 100.00 4492 21h 35m
PBcR pipeline 12 1889858 4667990 572347 8 2.03 0.35 99.91 4484 4h 35m
ECTools + runCA 12 4644297 4695577 956540 14 9.33 1.21 99.99 4494 11h 21m
Proovread + runCA 6 3523306 4674021 949310 8 5.73 0.32 100.00 4494 5h 42m
Pedobacter heparinus DSM2366 (genome size = 5167383 bp, No. of genes = 4339)
Abyss 44 1484728 5201989 403999 0 1.22 0.23 99.93 4309 90m
LoRDEC + runCA 30 1269137 5205089 792703 5 18.54 2.95 99.87 4329 2h 30m
PBcR pipeline 126 549480 5037466 73978 2 3.95 1.36 96.62 4075 15h 34m
ECTools + runCA 4 5164134 5177937 3895884 1 10.12 1.61 99.99 4335 8h 28m
Proovread + runCA 13 1561045 5181637 1269500 3 9.25 0.54 99.98 4329 12h 58m
Meiothermus ruber DSM1279 (genome size = 3097457 bp, No. of genes = 3105)
Newbler 44 509970 3071504 136299 0 0.33 3.65 99.16 3046 10m
LoRDEC + runCA 25 1082032 3138975 646109 10 2.71 20.64 99.97 3099 2h 52m
PBcR pipeline 6 1927798 3096677 1927798 0 4.20 18.37 99.83 3093 23m
ECTools + runCA 1 3095849 3095849 3095849 0 1.29 3.97 99.95 3101 7h 7m
Proovread + runCA 65 295928 3089235 88185 2 2.40 7.45 99.64 3043 3h 47m

a No. of mismatches/indels per 100 Kbp