Table 3.
Number of studies | Study enrollmenta | Study retentionb | Average retention rates | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Race or ethnicity | ||||
Hispanic | 5 | 586 | 511 | 82.8 |
African American | 10 | 1331 | 1059 | 83.5 |
African American, white and other | 8 | 1927 | 1763 | 92.1 |
Intervention target | ||||
Children | 3 | 413 | 388 | 91.1 |
Children and parent | 20 | 3431 | 2945 | 85.6 |
Body weight status | ||||
Overweight or obese | 9 | 1581 | 1314 | 79.6 |
All weights | 10 | 1523 | 1334 | 90.0 |
Body weight status not measured | 4 | 740 | 685 | 92.6 |
Study type | ||||
Prevention | 10 | 1523 | 1334 | 90.0 |
Treatment | 13 | 2321 | 1999 | 83.6 |
Intervention length | ||||
<1 year | 16 | 1658 | 1461 | 88.6 |
≥1 year | 7 | 2186 | 1872 | 81.1 |
Study type and treatment length | ||||
Prevention <1 year | 7 | 707 | 614 | 90.4 |
Prevention ≥1 year | 3 | 816 | 720 | 88.8 |
Treatment <1 year | 9 | 951 | 847 | 87.2 |
Treatment ≥1 year | 4 | 1073 | 873 | 74.0 |
Primary outcome | ||||
BMI or anthropometrics | 10 | 2342 | 2026 | 82.9 |
Other (behavior, physiology, etc.) | 13 | 1502 | 1307 | 89.0 |
Intervention settingc | ||||
School | 5 | 1273 | 1151 | 91.7 |
Home or community | 15 | 2410 | 2051 | 85.5 |
Laboratory | 2 | 126 | 102 | 81.1 |
Main intervention group | ||||
Nutrition or physical activity | 4 | 755 | 712 | 92.8 |
Nutrition and physical activity | 19 | 3089 | 2621 | 85.0 |
Study design | ||||
Randomized controlled trial | 19 | 2739 | 2440 | 89.3 |
Cluster randomized controlled trial | 2 | 745 | 656 | 75.6 |
Controlled trial | 1 | 235 | 136 | 57.9 |
Trial without control | 1 | 125 | 101 | 80.8 |
Mean age of childrend | ||||
<12 years | 15 | 2708 | 2333 | 86.2 |
≥12 years | 8 | 1136 | 1000 | 86.7 |
Number of intervention sessionse | ||||
≤12 | 7 | 752 | 636 | 86.3 |
≥13 | 15 | 2840 | 2445 | 85.5 |
Sample size | ||||
<100 | 9 | 493 | 435 | 86.9 |
≥100 | 14 | 3351 | 2898 | 86.0 |
aThe sum of numbers of participants enrolled in individual studies
bThe sum of numbers of participants retained in individual studies
cIntervention setting was not reported in the study by Weigensberg et al. [28]
d<12 years group includes one study with participants aged 8–14 years; ≥12 years group includes one study with participants aged 9–14 years, one study with participants aged 10–17 years and two studies with participants aged 11–16 years
eNumber of intervention sessions was not reported in the study by Azevedo et al. [17]