Table 1.
Summary of clinical trials of paracetamol for treatment of fever in children
Study (design; setting) | Patients (N; age range) | Treatments (n) | Regimen | Efficacy endpoint | Efficacy results (PARA vs. comparator) | Adverse events (PARA vs. comparator) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Versus NSAIDs | ||||||
Autret-Leca et al. [34]. (R, DB [1st dose]/OL [3 days], MC, PG; GP) | Fever (304; 0.25–12 years) |
PARA 15 mg/kg (150) IBU 10 mg/kg (151) |
Repeat dose for 3 days | AUC0-6 h |
Mean AUC0–6 h −7.66 vs. −7.77 °C/min (P = 0.82) |
Any AE 10.6% vs. 11.2% Infections 4.6% vs. 3.3% GI disorders 2.6% vs. 2.6% Respiratory disorders 2.6% vs. 2.6% |
Carabano et al. [35]. (PG; NR) | Fever, ≥38 °C (166; NR) |
PARA 15 mg/kg (80) IBU 7 mg/kg (86) |
Single dose | Change in temperature after drug administration |
At 1 h 37.80 vs. 37.66 °C (P = 0.22) At 2 h 37.29 vs. 37.09 °C (P = 0.14) At 3 h 37.28 vs. 37.12 °C (P = 0.64) At 4 h 37.46 vs. 37.40 °C (P = 0.72) |
NR |
Celebi et al. [59]. (R, PG; ED) | Fever (301; 1–14 years) |
PARA 15 mg/kg (112) IBU 10 mg/kg (84) KETO 0.5 mg/kg (105) |
Repeat dose for 48 h | Change in temperature after drug administration |
At 30 min 38.4 vs. 38.5 vs. 38.4 °C At 60 min 38.0 vs. 38.1 vs. 37.9 °C At 120 min 37.7 vs. 37.7 vs. 37.6 °C At 4–6 h 37.5 vs. 37.4 vs. 37.3 °C |
Early (< 6 h) vomiting 3.8% vs. 9.6% vs. 13.5% Late (6–48 h) vomiting 1.3% vs. 5.8% vs. 2.7% |
PITCH [60]. (R, SB, MC, PG; OP) | Fever, ≥37.8 °C and ≤41.0 °C (156; 0.5–6 years) |
PARA 15 mg/kga (52) IBU 10 mg/kgb (52) PARA + IBU (52) |
Repeat dose for 48 h | Time without fever in the first 4 h |
Time without fever in the first 4 h 219 vs. 211 vs. 202 min Time without fever in the first 24 h 1078 vs. 1029 vs. 1051 min |
Diarrhea 19.2% vs. 17.3% vs. 23.1% Vomiting 11.5% vs. 5.8% vs. 3.8% Rash 3.8% vs. 3.8% vs. 1.9% |
Wong et al. [40]. (R, DB, MC, PG; NR) | Fever, ≥ 37.8 °C and ≤ 40.5 °C (628; 0.5–6 years) |
PARA 12 mg/kgc (210) DIPYR 15 mg/kg (209) IBU 5/10 mg/kgd (209) |
Single dose | Patients with a temperature reduction of ≥1.5 °C |
Temperature reduction of ≥1.5 °C 77% vs. 86% vs. 83% Time to temperature reduction of ≥1.5 °C 109 vs. 103 vs. 120 min Normal (≤37.5 °C) temperature 68% vs. 82% vs. 78% (both P = 0.004 vs. PARA) |
Drug-related AEs 15% vs. 17% vs. 27% Vomiting 3.8% vs. 4.3% vs. 2.9% Diarrhea 2.4% vs. 1.4% vs. 1.4% |
Versus PL | ||||||
Gupta et al. [38]. (R, DB, PC; tertiary care) | Fever, ≥ 37.6 °C and ≤ 40.5 °C (210; 0.5–6 years) |
PARA 15 mg/kg (103) PL (107) |
Single dose | Fever clearance time [time to normal (≤37.5 °C) temperature] |
Median fever clearance time 32 vs. 36 h (P = 0.23) |
AE in first 6 h 8.7% vs. 0% |
Kramer et al. [61]. (R, DB, PC; home) | Fever, ≥ 38 °C and < 41 °C (225; 0.5–6 years) |
PARA 10–15 mg/kg (123) PL (102) |
Multiple dose q4 h | Duration of fever |
Mean duration of fever 34.7 vs. 36.1 h |
NR |
Parenteral PARA (i.e., PROP) | ||||||
Reymond et al. [84]. (Two studies; R, OL, PG; hospital) | Fever (10/24; NR) |
Study 1 PROP 30 mg/kg (5) ASA 15 mg/kg (5) Study 2 PROP 30 mg/kg (11) PROP 15 mg/kg (13) |
Single dose | Change in temperature |
Study 1: change in temperature −1.99 vs. −2.31 °C Study 2: change in temperature −1.79 vs. −2.11 °C |
Burning sensation during PROP infusion in 45% of patients |
Drug-dosage comparison | ||||||
Treluyer et al. [36]. (R, DB, PG; NR) | Fever, 39–40.5 °C (121; 0.33–9 years) |
PARA 30 mg/kg LD (62) PARA 15 mg/kg MD (59) |
Single dose | Rectal temperature |
Time to rectal temperature <38.5 °C 110.7 vs. 139.4 min (P = 0.05) |
Any AE 9.7 vs. 8.5% |
AUC 0–6h area under the temperature reduction curve-absolute difference in tympanic temperature from baseline at 6 h, ASA aspirin, DB double blind, DIPYR dipyrone, ED emergency department, GI gastrointestinal, GP general practice, IBU ibuprofen, KETO ketoprofen, LD loading dose, MD maintenance dose, NR not reported, NSAIDs non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, OL open label, OP outpatient, PARA paracetamol, PL placebo, PC placebo-controlled, PG parallel group, PROP propacetamol, q4 h Every 4 h, R randomized, SB single blind
aEvery 4–6 h
bEvery 6–8 h
cDosed according to age; average was 12 mg/kg
d5 mg/kg for T0 < 39.2 °C; 10 mg/kg for T0 ≥ 39.2 °C