Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 26;24(12):796–804. doi: 10.1136/bmjqs-2014-003151

Table 2.

Technical expert panel (TEP) ratings of included QI domains and per cent criterion met

# Domain Panel item Mean rating* % Criterion met†
1 Organisational motivation Description of the organisational problem/reason or motivation for intervention 2.78 64
2 Intervention rationale Description of rationale linking the intervention to expected effects 2.78 67
3 Intervention Description of specific changes in healthcare delivery organisation/structure 3.00 93
4 Organisational characteristics Description of organisational demographics and basic characteristics 2.89 89
5 Implementation Description of the approach to designing and/or introducing organisational changes 2.89 92
6 Study design Description of study design 2.89 44
7 Comparator n/a n/a 67
8 Data source n/a n/a 67
9 Timing Description of timing (intervention components introduction and evaluation) 2.78 56
10 Adherence/fidelity Description of intervention adherence/fidelity 2.78 47
11 Health outcomes Description of health-related outcomes 2.33 58
12 Organisational readiness Description of organisational readiness for the studied intervention 2.00 84
13 Penetration/reach Description of intervention penetration/reach 2.56 85
14 Sustainability Description of potential for intervention maintenance or sustainability 2.22 83
15 Spread Description of ability to be spread or replicated 2.11 89
16 Limitations Quality of the interpretation of findings 2.56 64

*Members (N=9) of an international TEP assessed independently whether the domain should (score=3), should maybe (score=2) or should not (score=1) be part of the Quality Improvement Minimum Quality Criteria Set (QI-MQCS). The respondents were instructed that the goal was to identify a minimum number of core domains; n/a: not applicable, the items were developed as a response to panel input.

†Percentage of publications meeting the criterion in psychometric evaluation sample (total N=54 publications, number of observations ranged from 18 to 45 as only the final item version was included in the analysis).