Table 2.
Study | Country | N (M/F) | Samples | P/N | Staning patterns | Cut off value | Lymph node metastasis | TNM stage | Differentiation | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||||||||||
CD133+ | CD133- | CD133+ | CD133- | CD133+ | CD133- | |||||||
| ||||||||||||
Negative/Positive | Negative/Positive | I+II/III+IV | I+II/III+IV | Well/poor | Well/poor | |||||||
Hou YC 2014 | China | 96 (63/33) | TMA | 42/54 | Cytoplasm | > 0% | 20/22 | 27/27 | 39/3 | 51/3 | 36/6 | 42/12 |
Kim HS 2012 | Korea | 42 (28/14) | Whole tissue sections | 14/28 | Cytoplasm and Membrane | > 3 | NA | NA | NA | NA | 10/4 | 21/7 |
Maeda S 2008 | Japan | 80 (52/28) | Whole tissue sections | 48/32 | Cytoplasm | > 0% | 11/37 | 18/14 | 42/6 | 28/4 | 48/2 | 31/1 |
Li XW 2011 | China | 35 (23/12) | Whole tissue sections | 26/9 | Membrane | ≥ 10% | 2/18 | 7/8 | 9/17 | 8/1 | 21/5 | 8/1 |
Wang X 2009 | China | 58 (36/22) | Whole tissue sections | 37/21 | Cytoplasm | > 0% | 14/23 | 17/4 | 18/19 | 16/5 | 22/15 | 17/4 |
Cen G 2010 | China | 71 (50/21) | Whole tissue sections | 46/25 | Cytoplasm and Membrane | > 5% | 10/20 | 33/8 | 23/7 | 36/3 | 10/20 | 33/8 |
Mizukami T 2014 | Japan | 17 | Whole tissue sections | 5/12 | Membrane | > 1% | 3/2 | 8/4 | 3/1 | 12/1 | 4/1 | 7/5 |
Chen K 2014 | China | 109 (71/38) | Whole tissue sections | 65/44 | Membrane | > 5% | 31/34 | 34/10 | 51/14 | 41/3 | 45/20 | 37/7 |
Wang YC 2014 | China | 52 (31/21) | Whole tissue sections | 39/13 | Cytoplasm | > 3 | 9/30 | 9/4 | 19/20 | 11/2 | 19/20 | 11/2 |
Shimizu K 2009 | Japan | 10 (4/6) | Whole tissue sections | 10/0 | Cytoplasm and Membrane | > 0% | NA | NA | 5/5 | 0/0 | 8/2 | 0/0 |
Vizio B 2012 | Italy | 37 (15/22) | TMA | 11/26 | Membrane | > 1% | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA |
Tsukamoto N 2013 | Japan | 80 | TMA | 29/51 | Cytoplasm | > 5% | 12/17 | 14/37 | 0/29 | 1/50 | 28/1 | 42/9 |
Abbreviations: N (M/F): number (male/female); TMA: tissue microarrays; P/N: positive/negative; NA unknown.