Skip to main content
. 2015 Dec 16;10(12):e0145349. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0145349

Table 1. Summary of the mutations, heterodimerization yields, production yields, and heterodimer-favoring and homodimer-disfavoring interactions of the isolated heterodimeric Fc variants from LibA libraries.

Paired mutations a Yield (scFv-FcCH3A/FcCH3B system) Main interactions d
Variant CH3A chain CH3B chain Heterodimer (%) b Production (%) c Favoring CH3A-CH3B Disfavoring CH3A-CH3A Disfavoring CH3B-CH3B
W-VT K409W D399V/F405T 60.8 ± 3.0 102 ± 31.1 K409WCH3A-D399V/F405TCH3B complementary hydrophobic interaction F405CH3A-K409WCH3A steric clash K392ECH3B unpaired charged residue K409CH3B unpaired charged residue
Variants from the LibA1 library constructed using a W-VT template with mutation pairs K409W CH3A -D399V CH3B /F405T CH3B
A107 K370E/K409W E357N/D399V/F405T 93.4 ± 1.1 (78.2 ± 4.2) 108 ± 51.1 (103 ± 49.0) K370ECH3A-E357NCH3B hydrogen bond K370ECH3A- S364CH3B hydrogen bond Y349CH3A-E357NCH3B hydrogen bond K370ECH3B-K409CH3B electrostatic interaction E357CH3A-K370ECH3A electrostatic repulsion
A108 K370E/K409W E357I/S364T/D399V/F405T 70.5 ± 3.3 125 ± 78.1 K370ECH3A-K409CH3B electrostatic interaction E357CH3A-K370ECH3A electrostatic repulsion
A109 K370M/K409W E357M/S364W/D399V/F405T 90.5 ± 2.7 (61.6 ± 4.5) 102 ± 27.2 (86.9 ± 2.1) K370MCH3A-E357M/S364WCH3B complementary hydrophobic interaction E357CH3A unpaired charged residue K370CH3B-S364WCH3B steric clash
A146 K370D/K409W E357M/D399V/F405T 74.5 ± 3.4 (71.0 ± 3.7)d 127 ±22.7 (89.5 ± 13.5) K370DCH3A-K409CH3B electrostatic interaction K370DCH3A-S364CH3B hydrogen bond K370DCH3A-E357CH3A electrostatic repulsion
Variants from the LibA2 library constructed using a A107 w/oW-VT template with mutation pairs K370E CH3A -E357N CH3B
A205 E357D/S364W/K370E E357N/K370R 88.8 ± 2.2 118 ± 5.0 S364WCH3A-K370RCH3B cation-π E357DCH3A-S364WCH3A anion-π repulsion K370ECH3A-E357DCH3A electrostatic repulsion Hole-hole interface
A210 E357A/S364Y/K370E E357N/K370H 80.8 ± 5.8 104 ± 9.2 S364YCH3A-K370HCH3B π-π, S364YCH3A-K370HCH3B hydrogen bond S364YCH3A-K370ECH3A anion-π repulsion Hole-hole interface
A216 E357G/S364W/K370E E357N 80.3 ± 4.6 92.1 ± 13.1 S364WCH3A-K370CH3B cation-π S364WCH3A-K370ECH3A anion-π repulsion
A241 E357N/S364W/K370E E357N 81.0 ± 3.9 150 ± 49.6 S364WCH3A-K370CH3B cation-π S364WCH3A-K370ECH3A anion-π repulsion

a Newly introduced mutations in the CH3A or CH3B domain of the isolated Fc variants are highlighted in bold. Other mutations were present in the template variant.

b Heterodimer yield (mean ± SD of three independent experiments) was determined by SDS-PAGE analyses under non-reducing conditions of the purified proteins after coexpression of the scFv-FcCH3A/FcCH3B proteins carrying the indicated CH3 variant pair in HEK293F cells as described in the text.

c The values represent relative purification levels (mean ± SD of three independent experiments) of Fc variants from HEK923 cells coexpressing scFv-FcCH3A/FcCH3B proteins for 6 days compared with the purification yield of the EW-RVT variant (3.1 ± 0.7 mg/100 mL culture).

In (b and c), the values in parenthesis are the heterodimerization and purification yields of the A107w/o W-VT, A109w/o W-VT, A146w/o W-VT, and B168w/o W-VT Fc variants, in which the W-VT mutation pairs were back-mutated to the corresponding wild-type residues.

d The heterodimer-favoring and homodimer-disfavoring interactions are those involving the newly introduced mutations on the CH3A or CH3B domain of the isolated heterodimeric Fc variants. Thus, the heterodimer-favoring and homodimer-disfavoring interactions from the parent template Fc variant should also be considered. The hole-hole interface means the absence of favorable intermolecular interactions at the CH3 domain interfaces due to less packing of amino acids with small-sized side chains. The minus “-” means that there are no particular repulsive interactions disfavoring CH3B-CH3B homodimerization, except for loss of the wild-type homodimer-favoring electrostatic interactions.