Table 1. Mean (SD) changes in fatigue and physical functioning and therapeutic alliance, by therapy and by therapist.
| Pragmatic Rehabilitation mean (SD), % missing | Supportive Listening mean (SD), % missing | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Therapist 1n = 34 | Therapist 2n = 29 | Therapist 3n = 32 | Therapist 1n = 32 | Therapist 2n = 35 | Therapist 3n = 34 | |
| CALPAS Total | 82.78 (14.42), 32.4 | 75.91 (23.80), 24.1 | 85.92 (17.68), 21.9 | 82.63 (14.33), 40.6 | 75.25 (14.64), 42.9 | 67.28 (18.63), 26.5 |
| Post-MI CALPAS Total | 82.28 (15.79), - | 76.27 (23.03), - | 85.52 (17.53), - | 80.81 (14.99), - | 75.97 (16.75), - | 64.92 (19.49), - |
| CALPAS Task Element | 63.81 (26.36), 34.4 | 53.33 (25.31), 31.5 | 46.90 (22.06), 14.7 | 69.13 (23.14)), 32.4 | 67.73 (30.54), 24.1 | 76.00 (22.55), 21.9 |
| Post-MI CALPAS Task Element | 64.98 (26.20), - | 55.94 (25.89), - | 45.40 (22.12), - | 67.11 (23.75), - | 67.12 (29.42), - | 75.34 (22.50), - |
| 20 week outcomes | ||||||
| Δ Chalder Fatigue (scored 0011) | -2.63 (3.78), 8.8 | -2.25 (3.53), 17.2 | -1.26 (2.75), 15.6 | -0.52 (2.40), 9.4 | -0.81 (2.65), 5.7 | -1.18 (3.06), 0.0 |
| Δ Chalder Fatigue (scored 0123) | -7.53 (9.40), 8.8 | -6.58 (7.65), 17.2 | -5.78 (7.18), 15.6 | -1.48 (6.52), 9.4 | -2.84 (7.31), 5.7 | -3.06 (6.29), 0.0 |
| Δ SF-36 Physical Functioning Scale | +2.00 (3.93), 8.8 | +2.52 (3.86), 13.8 | +1.69 (4.29), 9.4 | +0.34 (3.03), 9.4 | +0.22 (4.66), 8.6 | +0.85 (3.10), 2.9 |
| 70 week outcomes | ||||||
| Δ Chalder Fatigue (scored 0011) | -1.67 (3.56), 14.7 | -3.18 (4.27), 24.1 | -0.80 (2.75), 21.9 | -1.43 (3.44), 12.5 | -1.14 (2.83), 17.1 | -1.27 (3.16), 8.8 |
| Δ Fatigue (scored 0123) | -6.15 (8.88), 14.7 | -7.55 (8.20), 24.1 | -3.20 (6.71), 21.9 | -3.04 (8.63), 12.5 | -3.50 (8.23), 17.1 | -2.63 (7.23), 8.8 |
| Δ SF-36 Physical Functioning Scale | +2.57 (4.01), 14.7 | +3.50 (3.77), 17.2 | +2.04 (3.77), 15.6 | +1.17 (3.91), 9.4 | +1.24 (5.04), 17.1 | +0.69 (3.88), 5.9 |
Δ represents change in score from baseline to outcome, calculated by subtracting baseline scores from outcome scores.
Reductions in the Fatigue scale indicate improvement. Increases in the SF-36 Physical Functioning scale indicate improvement. A higher CALPAS score indicates stronger alliance. All CALPAS measures are at week 1. ‘Post-MI’ means post multiple imputation.