Table 2.
Authors | Year | Vitrectomy Technique | N (eyes) | Follow-up time (months) | RDa rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Park et al.22 | 1995 | ERMb removal | 98 | 11 (mean) | 14% |
Banker et al.18 | 1997 | No ILMc peeling | 95 | 12 | 11% |
Tabandeh et al.19 | 1999 | ERM peeling; No ILM peeling | 438 | 30 (mean) | 1.8% |
Brooks HL, Jr.9 | 2000 | ILM peeling No ILM peeling |
116 44 |
44.5 (mean) | 2.7% 4.5% |
Haritoglou et al.10 | 2002 | ILM peeling | 99 | 32 (mean) | 2% |
Ezra et al.23 | 2004 | ERM peeling; non-ILM peeling | 124 | 24 | 5.6% |
Kwok et al.13 | 2005 | ILM peeling No ILM peeling |
26 25 |
12 (mean) | 7.7% 4% |
Tognetto et al.8 | 2006 | ILM peeling No ILM peeling |
1100 527 |
15 (median) | 2.3% 2.9% |
Guillaubey et al.12 | 2007 | ILM peeling | 272 | 28 (mean) | 6.6% |
Patelli et al.20 | 2007 | ILM peeling | 24 | 10 (mean) | 16.6% |
Christenen14 | 2009 | ILM peeling Non-ILM peeling |
54 25 |
12 | 2.2% |
Rizzo et al.17 | 2010 | ILM peeling in all cases 20 gauge 23/25 sutureless |
301 656 |
6 | 1.2% 1.7% |
Passemard et al.16 | 2010 | ILM peeling | 135 | 37 (mean) | 7.4% |
Lois et al.15 | 2011 | ILM peeling Non-ILM peeling |
64 62 |
6 | 5% 3% |
Sakaguchi et al.7 | 2012 | No ILM peeling | 23 | 83.4 (mean) | 0% |
Wu and Kung21 | 2012 | ILM peeling | High myopia:8 Non-high myopia:34 |
7.0 (mean) 8.12 (mean) |
12.5% 0% |
Jackson et al.3 | 2013 | ILM peeling Non-ILM peeling |
1014 64 |
Unspecified | 2.4% (RD surgery) |
RD= Retinal detachment;
ERM= Epiretinal membrane;
ILM= Internal limiting membrane